Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
141 of 148 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
deciding between fluenz and rosetta stone, August 30, 2007
This review is from: Fluenz Version F2: Mandarin 1+2 (Win/Mac) with software DVDs, audio CDs, podcasts, and Navigator. Learn Chinese with the latest upgrade. (DVD-ROM)
When I decided to buy software to learn Mandarin, I thought Rosetta Stone was the only option. Luckily, I came across Fluenz before it was too late. At first, I was intrigued by Rosetta Stone's no-English rule and spent some time with their demo. But after comparing the Rosetta and Fluenz, I started to think the Fluenz method might be better. Sonia Gil, an English-speaking tutor, gives you tools to build phrases, and then sentences. The Fluenz linguists believe, and I tend to agree, that adults learn differently than children. By explaining key things in English, rather than having a bunch of Chinese thrown at them, adults can learn how to say many things very quickly. If you visit the Fluenz site you can see how powerful this is when it comes to learning phrases like "I need a taxi", or "I want a cup of coffee" in the first lessons. It would take weeks or even months for anyone to learn those phrases in Chinese the Rosetta way, by merely pairing images with their corresponding words. It seems difficult to learn a language without a teacher or tutor, and it is impossible to learn Chinese tones without a proper explanation.The Fluenz learning experience is further enhanced by its beautiful design. By comparison, the Rosetta V2 application, though nicely packaged, doesn't seem that up to date (once you pass the demo video, you can actually see what the real interface looks like). But the strongest point for Fluenz is the human element. Sonia takes the learner step by step, building skills that are practiced in a series of very creative workouts covering writing, reading, comprehension and expression. Overall, my experience with Fluenz has been great. I fully recommend the software for anyone interested in Mandarin.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|
|
|
53 of 53 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Fluenz, best language course for the buck!, August 29, 2007
This review is from: Fluenz Version F2: Mandarin 1+2 (Win/Mac) with software DVDs, audio CDs, podcasts, and Navigator. Learn Chinese with the latest upgrade. (DVD-ROM)
I ordered Fluenz Mandarin 1+2 for my upcoming tour of China (second tour in 6 months). I want to be able to communicate (even if only slightly) with the Chinese people.
Sonia(Gil)makes understanding and speaking Chinese very easy. ALL new words are explained and pronounced thoroughly and sentence structures are likewise explained. Other language courses may leave you guessing what was really said when converting to English. Not so with Fluenz! That was the selling point for me.
I did have a small problem with tone marked letters jumping out of sequence when doing my lessons and ending up with misspelled words. I got an email response from Fluenz (after they read my review on another site) instructing me how to correct this. It has sped up my lessons significantly and was a pleasant surprise to be contacted by the company without even asking for help!
I don't think you can go wrong by ordering this course. It's on the expensive side, but well worth the price!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|
|
|
59 of 62 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Learn Mandarin!, April 30, 2007
This review is from: Fluenz Version F2: Mandarin 1+2 (Win/Mac) with software DVDs, audio CDs, podcasts, and Navigator. Learn Chinese with the latest upgrade. (DVD-ROM)
Fluenz Mandarin is a comprehensive program for anyone wanting to learn Mandarin Chinese from scratch. It is meant for learners over the age of 13, and it would be quite useful both for those trying to establish a strong foundation before proceeding to more advanced or specialized work, as well as for those who need survival skills for business, travel or casual conversation.
The software follows a Mac aesthetic: clean, elegant, and modern. This philosophy goes well beneath the surface and can be felt throughout the program. The learning system -- which features a tutor on full-motion video guiding the learner every step of the way, a series of relentlessly challenging exercises, and the use of English to "leverage" the learning of Chinese -- are all very innovative. Fluenz Mandarin is composed of 45 sessions that cover essential vocabulary, grammar, and syntax by going over realistic interactions involving restaurants, giving and receiving directions, negotiating cabs and other forms of transportation, shopping, basic conversations, and even the 2008 Olympics. Each session can take up to three hours each, depending on the learner's speed.
Each session opens with the tutor, Sonia Gil, who led the development of the program and who guides the learner from beginning to end. She explains, gives context, motivates, and keeps the whole thing going with stories of her own experience with learning Mandarin in China.
After the introduction, there is a conversation that can be followed with or without subtitles (available in English and pinyin). Sonia follows with an explanation of every word and expression used. This is the heart of the method, since she systematically compares every word and expression in Mandarin with its counterpart in English. It seems straightforward and it is, but it makes a big a difference to anyone learning.
The tutorial is followed by a series of interactive "workouts." These start with a simple review of the vocabulary and basic expressions, move on to clever matching games, and then to actual writing. Learning to write is the only way to internalize different tones because writing provides a visual cue that helps the learner retain this most challenging part of learning Mandarin. The writing workouts combine both reading and writing, and then listening and writing, and they progress from simple words to more complicated expressions. The latter relies on an innovative color-coding scheme.
The workouts also make use of a recording device that allows the learner to record and compare her or his Chinese with that of native speakers. This device first deals with simple phrases, and then offers the learner an opportunity to insert her or himself into a conversation. After a couple of review workouts, Sonia comes back to conclude the session.
Like any software program that surpasses its many competitors in quality, effectiveness, and ease of use, Fluenz is its own worst enemy. After spending some hours learning Mandarin very fast, it's altogether natural for learners to want more and better, yet Fluenz thwarts that desire on a number of counts. For instance, the navigation doesn't allow learners to repeat a workout once completed. Moreover, there are instances in which sound would nicely complement written workouts, but isn't available. And more advanced sound recognition technology would make a difference. These are features that users should rightly expect to find in future upgrades of the software.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|