Customer Reviews

Flying Crows

5 star:		(6)
4 star:		(3)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

I'd never read any of Jim Lehrer's fourteen novels until this one and then only because my wife told me she thought I'd enjoy it. As a retired Kansas City psychiatrist, I was indeed fascinated by both the focus on Kansas City scenes and on the kind of treatment received by mental patients back in the 1920s and 1930s. But more than that I was caught up in the story of four men separated by generations, a 'lunatic' who murdered his family in 1905, a boy who witnessed Kansas City's 1933 Union Station massacre, a young doctor working in a 'lunatic asylum,' and a current-day Kansas City police officer. The story moves seamlessly back and forth between these periods in a way that is not only not confusing but is downright illuminating, managing to tell how the lives of these four men intersected. I admire the way Lehrer drops in historical detail in subtle ways so that we form in our minds a picture of the times. And I particularly liked the way he limned the humanity of all four main characters so that we not only find them interesting, we grow to care about them.

I would recommend this book to anyone, not just to those who are interested in midwestern history and the history of one of the most newsworthy events of the 1930s.

Scott Morrison

At the beginning, this book read as if it would be an expose on lunatic asylums in the first half of this century. After a start that was a bit slow, it turned out to be a warm mystery that was all about friendship.

In 1997, the Union Train Station in Kansas City is about to be demolished. When the police sweep the building to clear it, a man named Birdie is found. Birdie has lived in the station for 63 years. He was a former inmate of Somerset Asylum who escaped in 1933 and "moved in" to the Station. During his short tenure at the asylum, he is befriended by Josh who helped him escape. The book then flashes between 1933 (occasionally before as well for background) and 1997 to get the story. The policeman who found Birdie is intrigued and does some follow-up sleuthing.

About half-way through Mr. Lehrer's work, the reader is convinced that he has figured out a rather simplistic plot. That is not the case at all. There are some clever twists and turns that include the bloody massacre at the station in 1933 (that was part of Hoover's and the FBI's push to notoriety).

The plot line is very good. Although this really could not be classified as a mystery, there is some sleuthing and unexpected plot twists.

Primarily this is a book on friendship and loyalty placed in interesting settings and told through interesting characters.

I have enjoyed a few of Mr. Lehrer's books (Black Widow and Special Prisoner) and thought others not very good (No Certain Rest). This is by far his best. A warm book. Highly recommended.

In a well-told narrative, that goes back and forth two main protagonists in two different time periods, Lehrer examines complex ities and simplicties associated with life. The characters are earthy, realistic and distinctive. The book has its share of warmth, an element of pain, revolt and nostalgia. However, the premise, some elements of the plot, and the narrative technique of juxtaposing two different time periods has a strong resemblance to a Katzenbach novel (A madmans tale). Regardless, the plot's underpinngs lie in historical facts, which are well-researched. Lehrer manages to portray the grim incidents with a respectful sense of awe. A wonderful page-turner, not an entirely unique narrative technique or premise, but you will not be able to resist reading the novel in one sitting.

I found the book difficult to put down. It was a great read, with interesting characters, descriptions that pulled you into the story and a fascinating premise. I found myself disappointed at the end when all my questions were not answered but life is like that.
I am looking forward to reading other Lehrer books.

One of the most amazing books ever - yet so simple and undemanding. I found it hard to make myself stop reading, but I didn't really appreciate it til the very last line. I closed the book and simply sat saying "Wow," - not because of any stunning revelation - just a powerful story, simply told. A masterpiece.

While the writing and detail of the this book where good. The story line was pretty predicatble. Half way through (or less) you knew where this story was going to end up. Still it was charming none the less.

I have read several Lehrer novels. I believe he is a very underated author. All of his novels are very good. Others here have summarized the book. Lehrer does not high brow you, plain simple writing, easy on the reader. He usually has very good historical research interwoven into his novels. You feel good after reading one of his novels. The book is more about friendship and a description about mental hospitals in the 1920's. It is a good read.

I found that I had to plow through the first half of the book. Could not put it down the second half. Interesting plot. Well crafted. Mr Lehrer took me from detached to caring for his characters. Randy's perseverence in unraveling the mystery and his genuine empathy for Birdie made for a good story. Randy reminds me a little of Mr. Lehrer. I'm certain that he is persistent as he follows his leads when researching a story.
Thank you Mr. Lehrer for another good read.

I normally don't read fiction, but a friend talked me into getting and reading this book. It moved extremely fast and because there was a little history with the story, I loved every minute of it. I have now passed it along to another 7 people and have 4 more waiting to read it. Everyone that has read the book all say, what a great move it would make. History, sex, murder and more, the perfect movie script.

Lehrer's improbable yet fascinating plot takes unpredictable twists and turns. As a regular viewer of his impeccably factual nightly news program, I found his startlingly imaginative plot surprising and delightful.