Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Pack Your Bags!, February 9, 2009
A heavy block-of-a-book on the outside, Fodor's Italy 2009 (from the Full-Color Gold series) is packed with informative, well-organized and pleasingly presented material inside.
The entirety of Italy is an ambitious scope and Fodor's tackles it, with depth and breadth, according to geography: Rome; then northern Italy (e.g. Venice, Milan, et al); central Italy (Florence, Tuscany, and others); and southern Italy (Naples, Sicily, etc.). Each area gets some history, local culture, color photographs, and transportation info; but the emphasis is on vetted recommendations for sites/attractions, restaurants, lodging, entertainment and shopping. In urban areas, accompanying maps and charts convert the text into at-a-glance summaries.
I especially like the suggestions for walking and driving tours, and the "Need a Break?" recommendations for places to pause for a glass of wine, sandwich, pastry or gelato. The only odd and iffy aspect is the inclusion of "Word of Mouth" quotes from Fodor's online community of travelers -- mostly vacuous comments attributed only by screename -- that might fit on a casual website but strike a discord with this text's otherwise polished tone. Overall, the book's scope (and 960-page weight!) suit it best to armchair travel or as a starting point and planning tool -- indeed, I went from casual familiarity to an enthusiastic interest in visiting Italy as I read through this terrific guidebook.
|
|
|
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Incomplete, February 22, 2009
Having previously used Lonely Planet guides, this was my first Fodor's guide. In terms of information, the guide is good - a little lightweight, perhaps, in accommodation options. The layout could be better, however, a little thought into the arrangement of information would make it easier to quickly locate the desired pages. Don't bother trying to locate information on Sardinia, however - there isn't any... This is my biggest gripe with the guide - we are all familiar with regional guides with in depth information regarding a specific region (eg Tuscany) and it is sometimes hard to decide whether to buy the country guide or the regional guide. I usually go for the country guide to give me an overview of the entire country, so I am very disappointed that this guide does not cover Sardinia. Back to Lonely Planet for me.
|
|
|
5.0 out of 5 stars
Fodor'stalty 2009, June 7, 2009
An excellent, exceptional book on Italy !! Buy it, you will not be sorry you did. Bill S.
|
|
|
|