Most Helpful Customer Reviews
37 of 39 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Sparkling wit which works for me ..., March 22, 2001
I'm intrigued by the vastly differing opinions reflected in the reviews for this book. I think it's because different people read romance for different reasons. Me, I read for light fun and amusement, having done enough hard thinking by the end of a day's work. This is not to say that I read mindlessly - I still demand that my books, even romances, be well-written (i.e. no cliches, no poor prose, no dialogue which goes "clunk" onto the floor, please), and have basic integrity (i.e. be historically accurate and have characters and stories which don't require me to suspend too much disbelief). This book satisfies these requirements. It has these and the basic ingredients of a good romance (adversity, rescue therefrom, romancing, and so forth). Best of all, it has the wit to make me smile - the dialogue sparkles, there are many clever turns of phrase, and a strong sense of fun. I also like the fact that the plot doesn't runs along bog-standard melodramatic lines, but has enough eccentricity (off-centredness) to hold my interest, and some nice period touches too. A happy bonus is that the characters are likeable and warm (though I agree the grandmother is a dull villainess, she is too minor a character for this to bother me), and most of all charming and witty. Sax wins me over by his not taking himself too seriously and his thoroughgoing niceness (which his aristocratic insouciance saves from preciousness) and Meg is an honest woman of wit, though (justifiably, I think) a tad insecure and confused. Their humour makes them irresistable to me. I'm not one for the tortured and heartless knight who is miraculously redeemed by the love of a good woman (Sax is patently a kind man so him taking to unassuming Meg doesn't seem incredible to me), nor for the Great Trial of Love (mercifully the inevitable lovers' misunderstandings weren't over-blown). I like my romance with a light touch. If I wanted tormented souls, I'd read Thomas Hardy. If I wanted to be swept off my feet, I'd turn to Dorothy Dunnett's Lymond. If I wanted absolute period authenticity and sharp social comment, I'd pick up a Jane Austen. If I wanted to improve my mind, or if I wanted an unpredictable plot, I wouldn't turn to a romance! When I just want to be amused and entertained, without having my intelligence insulted, this book works well for me.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Forbidden Magic - Truly Magical, March 14, 2002
I don't know what the other reviewers were reading because I found this book delightful and quite, to the point, magical! I found Sax to be absolutely delightful, sexy, fun, and needy. I found Meg to be charming and also needy. They each saved one another. The entire household was a blast, including and especially the pets! The dialog just so spicy, sensual and fun! I'm wondering if these other people read the same book as I did! Granted, I am a big FAN of Jo Beverley, but I truly enjoyed this Regency romp and was sorry to see it end! Maybe the sister Laura's story could come next? Definitely a keeper!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Pagan Magic or Twist of Fate, September 26, 2007
This review is from: Forbidden Magic (Signet Historical Romance) (Mass Market Paperback)
Lord Saxonhurst "Sax" a handsome eccentric young lord, must marry in one day or have his hated grandmother choose his bride, when his housekeeper suggests a young lady who's family is down on their luck, he quickly agrees. Meg's parents died three months ago leaving her and her four siblings without any resources, when their landlord suggests giving her 15 year old sister to him as his mistress in exchange for room and board, Meg turns to a magical but dangerous statute for help. She wishes a way out of their predicament that would fit their station and when the offer to marry Lord Sax comes up she knows it is the answer to her dreams. When they go back to pack up their belongings Meg is unable to get the statute and attempts to go back to get it but discovers it gone. When their ex-landlord contacts her, he tells her that he has what she wants and she will have to do something for him to get it back. In the meantime, Sax's evil grandmother plots to get Sax to do her will. In the middle of all this, Sax and Meg find them selves happily drawn to each other.
This was a great story, but sometimes Meg was so stupid it made me angry especially with all her lies and her attempts to chastise others for their behavior. Otherwise very good.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
