7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
The Rehabilitation of Walter F. O'Malley, April 26, 2009
The writers Pete Hamill and Jack Newfield one night decided each would make a list of the three most evil people in history. When they compared the results, both lists had the same names: Adolph Hitler, Joseph Stalin and the former owner of the Brooklyn/Los Angeles Dodgers, Walter Francis O'Malley.
Non-baseball fans would no doubt be puzzled by O'Malley's inclusion on the list. But any lover of the game, especially a Brooklyn Dodgers fan, understood the hatred of O'Malley, who had taken the Dodgers to Los Angeles in 1958. In the half-century since, O'Malley has been branded a greedy villain who did more than move a franchise. He was the man who tore the heart out of Brooklyn.
Efforts by O'Malley's descendants and others to rehabilitate his reputation reach their zenith with Michael D'Antonio's new biography of O'Malley, which was produced with the full cooperation of O'Malley's children. I have read extensively in the field of baseball history, especially New York baseball history, and have encountered a lot about O'Malley, but always as a secondary character. It this volume, he takes front and center. I learned a lot about the man I didn't know before, especially his life before he began doing legal work for the Dodgers.
The O'Malley who emerges in these pages isn't a saint, but he fares far better than he does in most baseball literature. The idea that New York power broker Robert Moses was the true villain in the loss of the Dodgers isn't new--books by Neil Sullivan and Michael Shapiro also support that thesis--but it receives reinforcement here. O'Malley earns plaudits for his vision in bringing baseball to the west coast, for building a ballpark that's still considered one of the best, for supporting the player's early unionization efforts; and for his leadership of the game through times of turmoil. If O'Malley was guilty of anything, D'Antonio seems to conclude, it was destroying the myth that professional baseball was a sport, not a business (and in his view that's not entirely a bad thing).
O'Malley finally earned a plaque in the baseball Hall of Fame last year. Hamill still wasn't convinced that he deserved absolution, and this volume isn't likely to win him over either. But other fans may be persuaded to rethink their distaste for O'Malley.--William C. Hall
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
10 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
It was victory in defeat!, April 10, 2009
No one ever beat Robert Moses but Walter O'Malley was certainly a winner in the contest that pushed him out of his beloved Brooklyn. I was a Brooklyn Dodger fan as a kid. The book was slow in capturing me, but it did happen in chapter six which recapped the 1951 pennant race. From that point I was totally involved. D'Antonio was very kind to O'Malley and the O'Malley family. Perhaps, too kind. This is certainly a book worth reading if you are interested in baseball history. You get a glimpse into the politics of New York and the incomparable Robert Moses. Moses is a subject of study all to himself. See THE POWER BROKER by Robert A. Caro.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
D'Antonio's FOREVER BLUE take us behind the headlines to the story of the people, December 13, 2009
I have always felt that the true test for a writer is to take us beyond what we think we know about a subject, and reveal something that makes it more than a story and something more real. Michael D'Antonio has achieved this feat with FOREVER BLUE. Whatever you thought you knew about the players involved, the book takes you into dimensions that make the story more about people and how actions can set in motion a course that would have ripple effects for years to come. Bravo!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No