19 of 19 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Great product, worth your money, or at least a trip to the library, November 27, 2006
Zoe Yan
Forging the Sword by Hilari Bell
Hilari Bell's latest book, Forging the Sword, is probably her best book so far. Her previous books were very well written, too. I've been waiting almost a year for the end of the Farsala Trilogy to come out, and I have to say it was no disappointment. Forging the Sword is the conclusion of a fantasy story began in Fall of a Kingdom and Rise of a Hero. It doesn't stand alone very well, so be sure to read the first two books.
This book continues the story of how three protagonists, Soraya, Jiaan, and Kavi resist the Hrum invaders who try to conquer their country. The story is set in a fictional land, Farsala, which has marked similarities with ancient Persia. In the first two books, the Hrum defeated the Farsalan military and conquered most parts of the nation. Soraya, a former member of the deghan nobility, starts out as a conceited brat. The duty of responsibility, as well as her father's death, changes her. Jiaan is Soraya's illegitimate half-brother. He is one of the few that has both the skill and the courage to form another Farsalan army. Kavi is a peasant peddler who, after being maimed by an unscrupulous deghan years ago, hates nobility with a passion. The three of them start out as strangers with no commonalities and certainly no lost love among each other (not even among the siblings- remember, Jiaan is a "half-blood"). By the end of the second book, fate somehow manages to throw them together as the leaders of a motley conglomeration of ill-equipped Farsalan rebels. They hope that by keeping hold of several key cities and sabotaging Hrum equipment they'll be able to drive out the Hrum invaders.
Forging the Sword starts off at a brisk pace, pulling the reader in a headlong adventure. Unforeseen twists, plot turns, and daring escapades are carried out almost every chapter, and the writing is constantly infused with a steady stream of humor.
~The man stared at them.
"They've seen us," said Jiaan redundantly. "I wonder what they..."
The Hrum soldier stuck out his tongue.
"Is he...? You're kidding me," said Jiaan.
Four more Hrum scrambled onto the wall, shouting, "Come and get us! Come and get us, coward boys!"
"Coward boys?" said Jiaan. "They can't do better than that?"
The Hrum proceeded to do better.
"I can't quite hear him," Jiaan murmured. "I think... my father conceived me in... in...ah. You know, their Faran is pretty good. Anatomical."~
Some of our three protagonists' challenges are to hold the walled city of Mazad, to sabotage the Hrum siege towers, and to forge a sword strong enough to withstand Hrum watersteel. This is much harder than it sounds, due to the internal infighting and the increasing pressure put on by the Hrum military. Their biggest challenge is to learn to trust another- and that's harder than all the previous tasks combined.
Hilari Bell has once again crafted a masterful world as persuasive as it is creative. Most everything, from the language to the people, is based off of ancient Persian and Roman culture but remains interestingly unique. I especially like how the Persian myth of Rostam and Sohrab was incorporated into the story. The Hrum aren't cardboard cutout conquerors, either. They have their qualities and vices, just as any people have. Character development was fantastic. Soraya, who was my least favorite character in the first two books, is finally showing serious signs of maturing. The only problem I have with this book (and it doesn't bother me all that much) is the language. Certain words are used that might not be appropriate for kids not yet in middle school. Otherwise, Forging the Sword can, and will, appeal to young adults of all ages. Kudos to Ms. Bell!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Absolutely Amazing, December 29, 2006
Hilari Bell could not have written a better book if she tried. Forging the Sword was amazing. The captivating characters Soraya, Jiaan, and Kavi continue to evolve. They learn more about themselves and each other all throughout the book.
Honestly, it was a struggle to put the book down. There was not one dull part. You would think the war with the Hrum would get boring, or tiring at best, but it doesn't. Each character's chapter contributes something important to the overall plot and the ending is great. There are many unexpected and suspenseful twists and turns that keep you going. Overall, a great read. Enoy!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Terrific ending to a fantastic trilogy, March 9, 2007
Forging the Sword is Hilari Bell's final installment in the Farsala Trilogy. The books follow three people - Soraya, a deghass (noblewoman), her illegitimate half-brother Jiann, and the "everyman" peddler Kavi, as they work independently and then together to stop the invasion of the Hrum empire in their homeland of Farsala. If they can resist the Hrum from conquering every part of Farsala for one year, then they can claim their independence and be assured the Hrum will never invade Farsala again.
While the ending is fairly obvious (the author wouldn't take you through three books just to have the main characters lose the war), how she takes you there is quite the journey. Over the course of the books, the characters grow from being spoiled, arrogant and immature to people who have grown through their trials and the burden of saving a country. When we encounter Jiann, Soraya and Kavi in this book, they all have important roles that they take on reluctantly but well. Jiann is the commander of the rebel army, Soraya is a fledgling magician, and Kavi is the person who is able to inspire courage in the fighting peasants and gather intelligence for the rebellion. Together they all personify the legend of Sorahb, whose "story" is interspersed in the novel.
One thing that impresses me about Bell's novels is her ability to be very real and incredibly fair. In many novels, you have a "good guy" and a "bad guy" and that's that. But Forging the Sword is more complex than that. She lets us explore different characters on both the side of the rebellion and the Hrum and shows us that both sides have good motives - it's just certain characters who act without honor. Events in the first two books make it hard for even the three rebellion leaders to trust each other, but they come to realize they need to work through those differences for the greater good.
Overall, a solid read and highly recommended.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No