11 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Not a bad book, just not great, January 3, 2006
This review is from: Foundation XML for Flash (Paperback)
As I wrote about a month ago, I got the new XML book from Friends of Ed titled Foundation XML for Flash by Sas Jacobs. Now, I've been doing a bunch of XML work over the past couple of months and have gotten accustomed to using XML in my projects to do just about any kind of data updating, so I'm pretty well versed in writing loops around XML to retrieve data and to set up my buttons and all that. That being said, on to the book review:
The book definitely had its up accompanied by a couple of downs. Firstly, the thing I loved about the book is that if you have no prior experience with XML, this is the perfect book for you. It walks you through almost everything you need to know about XML and teaches you how to set up some pretty simple XML usage examples to get the grasp of all the possible properties of the XML object in Flash. As you progress through the book, you get into using the XML components, which is something I haven't even dabbled in personally for the simple fact that I prefer to have total control over my XML and I like to be able to edit/see the code to make sure I understand it (and since I wrote it I surely understand it...). The components definitely have their UPS, however, and its good for doing things like using web services or more advanced data binding.
Another thing I liked about the book was the fact that in the beginner chapters, where most beginners will learn the ropes of XML in Flash, Sas writes code that shows how to use pretty much all of the properties of the XML object, even though it's not the most efficient way of writing the code. She goes on to explain in the chapter summary how to more effectively write the code, but seeing the usage of some of those properties/methods is definitely helpful in case you're ever in a situation where you may benefit from them. The files the book uses are not available on a CD included, which is good because you don't have the hard CD cover sleeve in the back of the book making it impossible to keep it open and they're easily accessible from the Friends of Ed site (linked above) in the downloads section for the book.
Alternately, the cons of the book: For an XML for Flash book, there is way too much talk about Microsoft Office. I understand that sometimes this may come in very handy when your client gives you an Excel or Word file and you're going to have to convert it into XML, but personally I don't think that topic applies to too many people working with XML outside of a huge corporate environment. I know I've never been passed off any office documents and had to convert them into XML, but I do understand the need may arise sometime so it's not entirely bad to put this in, but I don't think it's necessary to write four chapters on it as opposed to breezing over it.
The database scripting language used in the book is ASP which I found kind of weird considering XML, like PHP, is a free technology and it would only make sense to use PHP for the database scripting examples. In Sas' defense, Friends of Ed has a book titled Foundation PHP 5 for Flash (which I also own and it is a very good book), so maybe covering some parts of it in ASP is not such a bad thing, just a personal preference for me to use PHP instead.
As I was forewarned by Pete Aylward, the Product Manager at Friends of Ed, that some screenshots in the book were printed at low quality. As promised, however, the good quality images were put online in case you need to refer to them at the Friends of Ed site.
Overall, as mentioned earlier, I think the book is great for people looking to dive right into XML who haven't had any previous knowledge of the technology. There are even mentions of things like XSLT and CSS along with other closely related technologies to make you aware of everything you need to know about XML. Get it, let it sink in, and enjoy the wonderful world that is XML and Flash. I promise you, you'll never want to do manual updating again.
On a related note, check out my XML image gallery source code to get some more insight into XML and Flash. It is fully commented to help understand what is going on in the file.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Learning to use XML structured data in Flash projects, April 9, 2006
This review is from: Foundation XML for Flash (Paperback)
This clearly written and well-organized book provides an overview of XML and how to use XML structured data in a variety of Flash projects. Anyone who is interested in working with XML in Flash and would like to learn more about how to get started will benefit from the easy-to-follow examples and the range of topics that the author has chosen to cover. Beginning with an overview of XML the chapters quickly move on to show how Flash can use XML data. The content is addressed to both Flash designers and developers. While Flash developers may already be familiar with the uses and specifications for XML schemas, Xpath, and XSLT; many Flash designers will gain an appreciation for many of the complexities of XML, as well as insight into the Web Services model. Later chapters, for example, reveal how to use Microsoft Word, Excel and Access to create XML content.
As one who can manage Flash ActionScripting, but who does not have a strong programming background, I found the background into the various XML types to be quite helpful. The book does an excellent job of explaining entities, relationships, schemas and how to navigate an XML object in order to show the how to use XML content with Flash. I was particularly interested in the many applications for e-learning and found the blend of author's screenshots, code examples and main text to provide a nice balance of learning styles.
I learned a lot from this work and am sure that it would be useful to people who are already familiar with Flash and want to learn more about how to use XML with this program.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Good book, but more about Office integration that I would like., January 19, 2006
This review is from: Foundation XML for Flash (Paperback)
This is a nice book to introduce someone to XML; however, it spends quite a bit of time on Microsoft Office integration with XML and Flash. This is a useful topic, but I would prefer the book be more aptly titled "Office XML and Flash". Not a bad buy for the money, but if you are looking for a hardcore XML and Flash book, this is probably not the one for you. If you have many clients that you believe would benefit from integrating their Microsoft Office 2003 suite with an online flash front-end, this would definitely be worth your time and money. I would estimate that at least 70% of this book is purely about using Office with XML. Again, not a bad buy, but keep the focus on Office in mind.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
