Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Proud Member of the Huey Lewis Discography, June 29, 2002
By A Customer
An album filled with cover--er, excuse me, "tribute"--songs is usually a bad sign. A sign that the band or performer has run out of original material and maybe the record company is breathing down his neck for a new release, pointing to the contract that he signed. And even if that's not the case, if the tribute album is produced with entirely noble motives, it may very well sound like a bad night at the karoke bar--missed notes, flat singing or worse.But that's not the case with Four Chrords, as I finally found out. I'm a Huey Lewis fan from way back and when this CD came out back in '94 I thought, "Oh no. This is the death knell for one of my favorite bands." But now I that I've finally listened to it, I know that I was wrong. Four Chords is a first-class production, handled by a group of singers and musicians who truly love good old fashioned rock & roll. I mean, their performance of "Little Bitty Pretty One" alone is worth the price of the CD.
|
|
|
7 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Decent Covers of Early Rock - But Ultimately Doesn't Capture the Essence of the Originals, September 2, 2005
When looking a cover albums, I put them into two categories: Those albums that pay tribute to a particular artist (such as the "Legacy: A Tribute To Fleetwood Mac's Rumours" in which many artists covered the tracks on Fleetwood Mac's "Rumours") and those in which an artist covers other tunes (Such as Barry Manilow's "Summer of 78" that cover songs from 1978). Most of the time, I am usually disappointed when it comes to either category. Whenever a classic song is covered, it is often very difficult to capture the essence of the original. In the case an artist puts out an album full of covers, it is often a very risky move. An artist will tend to do this when either they want a career boost or if they are at a point in their careers where they can afford the risk. In the case of Huey Lewis and the News, when they released "Four Chords and Several Years" ago, they had clearly reached that point where they could afford the risk. While there are some good covers on this collection, ultimately there seems to be something missing from this collection.
"Four Chords and Several Years Ago" is a cover of songs going back to the early days of Rock and Roll (late 1950s, early 1960s). In the 1980s, Huey Lewis and the News would peak with the albums "Sports" and "Fore". These albums were successful largely because of the style of Huey Lewis and the News. Namely, they would provide a nice mix of pop, rock, blues, honky-tonk, and retro sounds. On the "Fore" album, Huey Lewis and the News showed they could pay homage to the early days of Rock and Roll with the song "Naturally". This was a song that had a Doo-Wop feel and it was sung a cappella. While Huey Lewis has always incorporated a retro sound, this song would prove that Huey Lewis and the News were more than capable of delivering.
When it comes to early Rock and Roll, many people associate Doo Wop music with this period. I think it's valid to say that Doo Wop is a sub-genre of early Rock and Roll. There is some debate on what Doo Wop exactly is. I classify Doo Wop to be the style of early Rock and Roll that lent itself to those songs that had upbeat extended harmonies - sometimes they are vocal syllables as opposed to words. One thing that almost all of the sub-genres of early Rock and Roll have is that there is a heavy influence of Rhythm and Blues. While the song "Naturally" on "Fore" demonstrated Doo-Wop, Huey Lewis has always demonstrated a Blues influence throughout their career. So it makes sense that Huey Lewis would put together a collection of early Rock Songs with a strong Blues influence. There are some Doo Wop style songs on this collection (for example: "Mother-in-Law", "Little Bitty Pretty One", "Stagger Lee", "Surely I Love You"), but I still think the Blues influence is what Huey Lewis and the News aimed for.
"Four Chords and Seven Years Ago" includes 17 tracks. These might not be the best known early Rock tracks, but I give the band credit for including this on the collection. According to the liner notes, these tracks were recorded as they were in the 1950s - namely without the use of sophisticated computers and remixing. I give Huey Lewis and the News and producer Stewart Levine a lot of credit for this. Of these 17 tracks, there are only 2 tracks over 3 minutes and 20 seconds ("Good Morning Little School Girl" and "Better to Have and Not Need"). This keeps in tradition that the early Rock and Roll songs usually would clock in somewhere in between 2 and 3 minutes (so they would get radio airplay). Here are the 17 tracks and artists that are covered by Huey Lewis and the News
Shake Rattle and Roll (Big Joe Turner, Bill Haley and the Comets)
Blue Monday (Fats Domino)
Searching for My Love (Bobby Moore's Rhythm Aces)
Some Kind of Wonderful (The Drifters)
But It's Alright (JJ Jackson)
If You Gotta Make A Fool Of Somebody (Freddie and the Dreamers)
Mother-In-Law (Ernie K Doe) - Dr. John is featured on the track on this collection
Little Bitty Pretty One (Thurston Harris)
Good Morning Little School Girl (Johnny Winter)
Stagger Lee (Lloyd Price)
She Shot A Hole In My Soul (Clifford Curry)
Surely I Love You (Rosco Gordon)
You Left The Water Running (Otis Redding)
Your Cash Ain't Nothin' But Trash (The Clovers)
Function At The Junction (Shorty Long)
Better To Have And Not Need (J.Blackfoot)
Going Down Slow (St. Louis Jimmy Oden)
While Huey Lewis and the News do an admirable job with this, something seems to be missing. There isn't that standout track that you are going to run back and say "Wow Huey Lewis and the News really captured that song". To me, if I want to hear these songs - I would much prefer them to be done by the original artists. While Huey Lewis and the News come close, there still nothing is like the original. In fairness, the band doesn't lose any points on these covers - they just didn't excite me all that much.
Some credit has to go to the covers of "If You Gotta Make a Fool of Somebody", "Mother-In-Law" and "Stagger Lee". These are the best two covers even though "Some Kind of Wonderful" and "But It's Alright" got all the airplay.
The liner notes do not contain any lyrics. They do contain the musician and production credits for this collection. There is a terrific write-up that gives some perspective for the making of this collection. Although the liner notes do reference some of the original artists who covered these tracks, I'm disappointed overall that they don't list all the original artists who covered these tracks. Overall, this collection is good - but doesn't bowl me over.
|
|
|
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Ain't That Ironic?, December 15, 2005
The one must-own album that Huey Lewis & the News ever put out is in the "Shame It's Out-of-Print" File. That's perfect. Say what you will about all the inoffensive, catchy, and forgettable hits these guys churned out in the mid to late 80's. On this album, a collection of covers of 50's and 60's rock standards, they were tight and sharp and in their best form. "Stagger Lee," "(She's) Some Kind of Wonderful," and "Better to Have and Not Need" are standouts, but the whole thing is great for lovers of old-fashioned rock 'n' roll. Track down a copy at a record 'n' tape exchange somewhere. It's worth it.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|