Most Helpful Customer Reviews
2 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Horrifyingly disappointing, August 17, 2007
This movie starts out like some sort of glorious hybrid of several non-Movie horror classics - Shirley Jackson's "The Haunting Of Hill House", the videogame "Silent Hill 2", a smattering of Koji Suzuki's "Dark Water" collection, and with elements of Steven King, William Peter Blatty, Stanley Kubrick, Ira Levin and so forth.
And then, somewhere around the halfway mark of this 97-minute exercise in disappointment, it all goes horribly wrong, and the gorgeous cinematography, interesting premise and truly creepy and tense feeling of impending doom are wrenched cruelly away from the viewer, and are replaced with one of the most anticlimactic second halves I've ever seen in movies.
Amy Nicholls (Flockheart) is an American nurse with a tragic past, recently come to Mercy Falls Children's Hospital on the Isle of Wight to take up the post of staff nurse. She befriends a troubled little girl named Maggie, whose imaginary friend is a whole lot more real than either Amy or any of her colleagues could imagine.
Firstly, the acting's not the main draw in "Fragile" - Flockheart, Richard Roxburgh and Gemma Jones do very good jobs in their roles - Flockheart must be praised for a convincing first half performance, and then for doing her level best with the apalling script in the second half. The kids are child actors - not terribly good ones, but not so bad as to make you want to switch off - and, while there are one or two dreadful performances turned in by the likes of amateurish Colin McFarlane and histrionic Elena Anaya, all in all, the actors, while decent enough, take a very marked back seat to the talents behind the camera.
Xavi Giménez's eerie, haunting, expressive cinematography and Jaume Balaguero's outstandingly tense direction deserve huge praise - even in the let-down latter half of "Fragile", the visuals retain a charisma and a genuine tension that are worth seeing. The special effects are good, too, with next-to-no CG animation to muck up the reality of a surreal situation, we are totally hooked by the desolate, rain-swept countryside vistas and the long, foreboding corridoors and wards of a near-abandoned hospital.
Sadly, the visuals can't save the script - it's a mess. Given the beginning, it's like this movie ought to have had a different ending - more Hitchcock, more Hideo Nakata, and a hell of a lot less Hollywood Horror - but somewhere along the line it was decided to tack on an ending that's someone's idea of "accessible" - and this does "Fragile" the biggest disservice, by turning a carefully crafted sense of mystery and despair into Just Another Horror. Amy's burgeoning romance with Dr. Marcus isn't resolved, neither is the mystery of her sad past - and the "twist" in the tale is revealed with such bald flatness that you might just turn the DVD player off before the final credits roll.
Don't bother seeing this movie, it's certainly worthwhile in the beginning, but the intense and crushing disappointment of the latter half will negate any satisfaction you'll have amassed.
Avoid.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Calista Flockhart in a Spanish-Made Horror Film: Decent But Not Special, September 17, 2006
You may not believe me, but it is true. Calista Flockhart, best known for her delightful (or irritating, depending on your perspectives) turns in the popular TV series `Ally McBeal' is now in a Spanish horror film (in which all the characters speak English, though). Director Jaume Balagueró (`Darkness') successfully delivers a spooky mood of a rundown hospital on the Isle of Wight, where a sad-faced American nurse Amy (Calista Flockhart) is transferred from London for the night-shift work.
But we know better than she does. In the effective opening sequences, we know that there is something weird going on in The Mercy Falls Children's Hospital, very old facility that is going to be shut down soon; that is, one of the patients, little girl Maggie says `she is coming' and a little boy experiences a nasty and painful thing.
`Fragile' is most scary in the first half, where everything is put in the right place, all contributing to creating the creepy feeling of a haunted house. The tricks themselves are not new, but all nicely handled - such as strange noises, the sealed and deserted second floor, a mysterious `mechanical girl' and some old history of the building. Cinematographer Xavi Giménez (`Darkness' `The Machinist') did a fine job, capturing the creepy images of the dark interiors of the hospital.
But as in `Darkness,' Jaume Balagueró tries to do too much in the second half. The film implies not only Amy's tragic past, but the love interest for her, a doctor played by dull Richard Roxburgh, and the more it tries to encompass, the more plot holes start to be seen. And as to the acting, sorry to say this, but the kids are better than the adults. Calista Flockhart shows a surprisingly good performance at first, downplaying the role of tormented Amy, but sadly she starts to overact in the last half, where she keeps screaming and rolling her eyes.
You notice `Fragile' shares the same theme as `Darkness' - missing children, for example - and probably `Fragile' will be better received by American audiences than the other (if it is not heavily cut, of course). It is deeply flawed, but is still a good choice for a sleepless night.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
0 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
IT CHANGED MY LIFE, May 13, 2009
This review is from: Fragile (Fragil) [NON-USA FORMAT, PAL, Reg.2 Import - Spain] (DVD)
!Una pelicula muy fabulosa! After experiencing this film, I don't need an astrophysicist to tell me there are eleven dimensions. I was especially moved by the "Nicholas" character. Genius!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
