From School Library Journal
Grade 4–7—Twelve-year-old Nate Fuller returns to solve another mystery alongside his famous mentor, Harry Houdini. In 1911 Manhattan, a prominent stockbroker is the victim of a gruesome murder. Nate is shocked when his good friend Ace, who works for Houdini, is arrested as the "Fifth Avenue Slasher." Both Nate and Houdini are sure that Ace has been framed, but the District Attorney, up for re-election and wanting to wrap up the case, is unwilling to see beyond the incriminating evidence. Nate and Houdini enter the seamy Bowery district to track down the clues that will exonerate their friend. Meanwhile, a younger cousin is dropped off on the Fuller doorstep by her father, who is eager to head west to seek his fortune. While young Allie's presence seems to be an unnecessary distraction through much of the story, she does play a part in its resolution. Lalicki's research into the period and his extensive knowledge of Harry Houdini are evident. As with Nate's past adventures, the coincidences stack up a little too neatly, but the rollicking action and tough-talking characters are appealing. Purchase where the first two books are popular.—
Kim Dare, Fairfax County Public Schools, VA Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Review
“This third book in Lalicki’s acclaimed Houdini and Nate Mystery series delivers action, appealing characters, and contemporary issues within an engaging historical context.” —VOYA
“Lalicki’s storytelling continues to make good use of historically accurate details while leaving the plot and character development unburdened by explanations that could distance readers from the excitement.” —Booklist Online