Customer Reviews

Frank Miller: The Art of Sin City

5 star:		(4)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(2)

 

 

I have been a huge fan of Frank Miller since his Wolverine mini-series done in the late 80s. I'm a huge Sin City fan, and I own all of the graphic novels, even though I also own most of the individual issues, so you can imagine my joy when I heard this project was first announced. It arrived today from Amazon, and I'm returning it tomorrow morning. This book is about 90 percent reprints of pages from the various Sin City mini series, and some promotional items, with perhaps a dozen or so rough layouts and sketches. There were exactly 4 images in this book that I hadn't already seen!!! I can't believe he would try to milk [$$]from his fans like this!!! If you own the majority of the graphic novels in this series, don't waste your money on this. There is very little about his thought or design processes. If you haven't read any of the books in this series, this is a good teaser for the full graphic novels.

I bought this hoping that it would wash the bad taste of DK2 away, but now I feel doubly cheated.

It's really a shame that Sin City fans are responsible for this book's poor overall rating. The title says it all- it's about the ART of Sin City, so people who want to see all original material should just wait for new Sin City comics and stop complaining about this book.

With that said, I should really take a moment to compliment Dark Horse for producing books like this and The Art of Hellboy, both of which are valuable to artists like me who do not read comics but are in awe of many of the artists who work in the field. I could name many artists who I wish had books like this one- compilations of finished art and sketches that showcase the art in large format and take the readers/viewers behind the scenes of how it was produced.

If you are an artist who is looking to master the aesthetics of black and white design, I highly recommend both this book and The Art of Hellboy. I also recommend both books if you are a fan of art and enjoy discovering complexity in what appears to be simple, and vice versa. However, if you have every Sin City comic and are distraught because you bought this book expecting it to be all new material, then do us artists and art fans a favor and put your copy back on the market.

I saw this in a comic book store and boy, was this a disappointment. Most of the material has appeared in the pages of the Sin City comic books. Here, they're reproduced at a larger size but big deal. Compare this to the recent Art of Hellboy and you'll see a huge difference in terms of value. Do not buy this book if you already own the Sin City comics or graphic novels because you're going to be getting something you've already seen.

This book is sealed by plastic warp. And is brand new as described. Just a reminder if you are looking for the Comic book writer, author of Sin City, Frank Miller-- this is not the same artist, but some older illustrator with the same name.

If you're a fan of graphic novels, you're no doubt familiar with Frank Miller and his unique art style. This book serves to collect all the best visuals from the Sin City series and even throws in some sketches and promotional art that you probably haven't seen. Because the book is also oversized at 11x14 you get a better look at some art that in the original books is much smaller. It also does a good job of collecting all the best panels from the series and showing how Miller's style shifts from book to book, and the hardcover especially will allow you to keep the collection for years to come. It's a great book, filled with tons of great art that you'll no doubt flip through often for inspiration or just to see some great work. The only reason I gave this 4 stars, and not 5, is that to get the full effect you really should read all 7 books of the Sin City series and see these featured panels in their intended form.

Innovative technique, closer to fine art than comic illustration.
I would like to know if Miller does all of this work, or oversees other artists.
If the later, they should be given credit.

Sin City has always been one of my favirote books out there. I have always wondered how Frank Miller managed to get the book to look so good. So when I heard about this art book, I jumped on it. It completely blew me away! It has several scenes that they break down for you. It also has the different drafts that Frank went through to get single pages done.

Im sure that you think, "well, art books cost a ton!" But, this one only costs around [fairly decent priced]! Plus its worth every penny! Young Artists, Sin City fans,and anyone who likes good art should pick this up!

It wont disapoint you!