88 of 89 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
great features, bad design, February 25, 2001
This review is from: Franklin EBM-901 eBookman (Metallic Black) (Office Product)
I preordered this from Amazon back in early December and finally received it last week. After playing with the EBM-911 for a week, this is my impression of it.
The Good: Big screen size compared to other PDA's. The ability to listen to music and audio books as well as basic PDA functions. The main reason I bought this thing was for its ebook capabilities. I had my doubts but reading on the eBookman is not bad at all, the text is very sharp and clear. I just hope Microsoft releases the MS Reader soon so I can actually start downloading stuff I actually want to read since there is not that many titles available in the Franklin reader format.
The Bad: If anyone is thinking of buying this primarily for its mp3 capabilities, don't. You would be happier getting a dedicated MP3 player. The eBookman doesn't play mp3's; you'll need to convert your mp3's to Franklin's proprietary compression format. I can live with that but wish the sound quality was a tad better. The two songs I transferred sounded a bit worse than FM quality. Also, on my unit there was a high-pitched humming noise that was emitting from the tiny speaker. It's not noticeable at all unless it is totally quiet in the room, very annoying if you are trying to read in bed. The eBookman is not easy to setup, you'll need to download the manual from Franklin since the quick start guide included in the box is useless. Buggy software.
The Ugly: I just changed the battery the other day and everything was gone when I turned the unit back on. I had to transfer the OS and applications all over again! I removed the battery two more times to see if it would happen again and it did. Imagine that you are on a trip and do not have access to the computer that syncs with your eBookman and your battery runs out...can you say screwed big time? I understand now why they sell the power adapter accessory for the eBookman.
I like the features that the eBookman has, it is everything that I would want or use in a PDA but I don't know if I would have purchased it if I had known about the issue with the battery. Losing all of its memory every time you change the batteries is a big problem.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
19 of 19 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Great deal for the money!, January 30, 2004
This review is from: Franklin EBM-901 eBookman (Metallic Black) (Office Product)
I've read other reviews for this product that have people complaining about losing their data when the batteries are changed. THIS IS NOT TRUE if you're carefull. First of all, my ebookman came with a bright blue warning flier stating that your ebookman needs to be turned OFF when you change the batteries. Pretty simple, huh? Also, don't wait for your battery to completely die before you change it. The main menu screen has a battery meter in the bottom right hand corner, and I just switch out the batteries when the meter reaches 10%. I primarily use my ebookman to read ebooks and I love it!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
28 of 30 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Normal launch at hot market, February 26, 2001
This review is from: Franklin EBM-901 eBookman (Metallic Black) (Office Product)
I think Franklin has done good job in sensing the eBook readers have great potential in near future. The eBookMan seems to have arrived a bit earlier, though. The lack of documentation is really disappointing, especially this is eBook reader, after all: I expected that the manual will be in the device itself! Well, the good side is that it can at least easily be fixed in future releases. Here are few advices to other enthusiasts:
- Do not expect easy start; eBookMan will be probably great after another few months. Since it is mainly the software that needs improvement, you may consider purchasing the device now and playing with it;
- Publishers should wait for Microsoft's reader release; the Franklin viewer does not justify investments yet; then again, there is also a MobiPocket reader, so consider that as well.
- Consumers, buy from Amazon, not from Franklin's website: it's cheaper and arrives faster (I got mine from FEP, I know)
- Form factor is good for reading ebooks, screen is clear and if you don't mind the high pitch in quiet rooms it's OK
- Get the 911 model, the 901 does not have enough memory!
- There are still only few places you can get any additional info/software for the eBookMan: I highly recommend the Yahoo! egroup "eBookMan", which was created recently by eBookMan enthusiasts; they have growing list of resources for the device, eBook references and eBookMan third-party application sites
Conclusion: eBookMan has a lot to grow yet, but I think what matters is that the concept beyond it allows for it; it will come at no cost to Franklin and customers to continue upgrading the experience. At present, it is unclear whether Franklin will be able to hold to it, but it surely has a chance.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No