From School Library Journal
Grade 4-7–This first tale in this series is narrated by a knight who calls himself a "free lance," a warrior who wanders on his own instead of promising his loyalty to a particular lord. Traveling through the Badlands, he seeks to secure enough money for shelter and food to last the winter. Lured to a village to participate in a tournament, he finds himself swept into the local lord's greedy plans. If the knight can retrieve a magical crown from the Lake of Skulls, he will be well rewarded. The task seems easy until he encounters a hag complete with "slavering teeth" and "a razor-sharp scythe." The story contains numerous fight scenes in which heads are bludgeoned or totally removed. Though accompanied by pen-and-ink illustrations that show the mostly evil and unattractive characters, the text lacks imagery. Readers may long for more information about the central character's past. The action seems too hurried and the knight's skirmishes are too easily won. Although this story has the blood, battles, and setting for a true Middle Ages adventure, the characters are lacking in heart and history.
–Erin Gray, Brentwood Branch Library, Springfield, MO Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
--This text refers to an out of print or unavailable edition of this title.
Review
This is one knight who survives not just by being heroic - a pile of skulls is testimony to those who've tried this - but on his own wits. -- Waterstones Books Quarterly 20030601 Raymond Chandler goes to Camelot ... Narrated in a hard-bitten, sardonic voice ... aimed at children of 10 upwards whose reading ability is some way behind their chronological age, but it could be equally enjoyed by word-savvy eight and nine-year-olds. -- TES 20030829 Owes a lot to Beowulf and more to pulp fiction: close scrapes with monsters and villains, wisecracks, double and triple crossings and plenty of Tarantinoid violence. The language has the easy clarity of a Paul Jennngs story with a similar wealth of episode ... The energy of Riddell's line drawings matches the hectic pace of the storytelling. One for the lads? All the females are villainous and most end up dead, so it should go down well amongst some of them at least. -- Books for Keeps 20040301 Suitable for pupils of 11 years up ... written to appeal to less able readers ... Funny with a good line in irony ... There are some hefty examples of similes to appeal to the English teacher. The premise of the story and the settings are really clearly described and illustrated so that the reader willl have a good picture of the situations in his head. ... an engrossing story for this age group ... it is likely that having read this one readers will be looking for more. -- School Librarian 20040304