"A well-crafted and enlightening work that should prompt similar comparative studies on regiments from other states."
-
The South Carolina Historical Magazine"The importance of Reid's work is not that it reiterates the similar experiences of black soldiers, but displays their differences. . . . Gives historians an excellent comprehensive view with fresh insights of African Americans who served in the Union army."
-
Louisiana History"The first state study of African American soldiers in the Union army. . . . A very readable narrative. . . . Succeeds admirably."
-H-Net Reviews
"Will become essential reading for its scholarly audience--and it will probably fare well among popular readers."
-
West Virginia History"A richly detailed account. . . . Skillfully combines military and social history."
-
The Register of the Kentucky Historical Society"Informative, well-written, and has enriched the historical literature on African American men in the ranks of the Union army."
-
Journal of Military History"An excellent social history of North Carolina's African American regiments in the civil war. . . . Superb scholarship and a model for future state-level social histories of Civil War military service."
-
Journal of American History"The most thoughtful and thorough regimental history of the U.S. Colored Troops yet to appear. . . . Points the way toward state and regional studies as a fruitful approach to the history of black military participation in the Civil War."
-
North Carolina Historical Review"Informative . . . effectively synthesizes military and social history, extends our understanding of the challenges confronting African-American Civil War soldiers and veterans, and suggests future areas of investigation."
-
Georgia Historical Quarterly"Outstanding. . . . Provides an invaluable window on the black experience in the Civil War era."
-
Journal of Southern History"A valuable contribution to the growing body of literature on the African American experience during the Civil War era. . . . Yield[s] fresh insights into some neglected areas of the black soldiers' experience."
-
American Historical Review"The first state study of African American soldiers in the Union Army. . . . Promises new research possibilities beyond the traditional view of patriotic black troops sacrificing for the Union. . . . Recommended."
-
CHOICE"An admirable addition to our knowledge of a cross-section of black regiments."
-
America's Civil War"A welcome contrast to the usual regimental-level studies of Blacks in union uniforms."
-
Multicultural Review"Provides a new understanding of the spectrum of the black experience during the Civil War."
-
Courier"Expands the understanding of state soldiers. . . . Some fine illustrations; the bibliography lists major works on black soldiers in blue. . . . Recommended."
-
Choice"This well-researched and well-argued book should stand as the definitive history of North Carolina's four black regiments in the Civil War."
-John David Smith, University of North Carolina at Charlotte