From School Library Journal
Grade 6-9 - Four friends are undecided about whether or not they should include the new girl, Hannah, in their group. When Tory invites the newcomer to her 14th birthday party at her mother's insistence, Hannah begins to spread rumors among the girls. They believe the half-truths about one another, and in turn doubt their friendships. Hannah is able to smooth things over, but continues to stir up trouble. The truth about Hannah's behavior is eventually revealed: her father has been imprisoned, leaving her devastated. Narrated by Tory, the story touches upon the struggle between loyalty and honesty among friends and the need to treat outsiders with sympathy, themes that will ring true for many readers. The plot snaps along at as brisk a pace as the characters' lives: everyone has a cell phone and rumors spread quickly. The relationships are strong and realistic. While the use of British terms and slang might confuse some readers, this novel will appeal to those who like contemporary stories of friendship.
- Karen Hoth, Marathon Middle/High School, FL Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
--This text refers to the
Hardcover
edition.
Gr. 6-8. Fourteen-year-old Tory is charged with seeing that Hannah, the new girl in school, feels welcome. As Tory's mother tells her, "It costs nothing to be nice to people." But keeping moody, inscrutable Hannah entertained while maintaining bosom friendships and working toward dating boys is draining. Is the real Hannah just a vulnerable, "shy little thing" with a painful past? Or is she a "two-faced, manipulative" vixen who intentionally tells half-truths to sabotage Tory's closest relationships? British author Rushton puts a refreshing spin on the "mean girls" theme, complicating the cliched dynamic between powerful clique and victimized outsider. The result is a thought-provoking psychological mystery, capped with a climax and a denouement that will leave readers pondering the circumstances of Hannahs in their own lives. A plot point involving self-mutilation feels tacked on, and readers who look to realistic fiction for accurate reflections of their lives may find the British context distracting. Others, however, will appreciate this nuanced portrayal of adolescent friendship--and the honest exploration of its limits.
Jennifer MattsonCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved
--This text refers to the
Hardcover
edition.