Customer Reviews

Fundamentals of Machine Component Design

5 star:		(4)
4 star:		(3)
3 star:		(2)
2 star:		(2)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

This is a textbook for mechanical engineering design and also a reference book for practicing mechanical engineers. It is assumed that the reader has had courses in statics, dynamics, strength of materials, and material science. In other words, it is assumed you are the equivalent of at least a junior undergraduate in mechanical engineering.

The first section of the book functions as a fast-paced review of the aforementioned prerequisites. Don't expect elementary straight numerical problems even in the introductory section. The author gets down to business immediately with example problems that involve actual mechanical devices. The example problem solutions are excellent with separate solution sections labeled "Known","Find", "Schematic and given data", "Assumptions", "Analysis", and "Comment". Each chapter has solutions to a few of the many exercises. Of particular interest in section one is chapter 8,"Fatigue", and chapter 9, "Surface Damage". Chapter 8 is important because it contains a simplified, condensed, and introductory version of fatigue design and fatigue crack growth, and is probably going to be new material for many readers. Chapter 9 deals with the various kinds of surface deterioration in machine components. This is important because more machine parts fail because of surface damage than from actual breakage.

Part two of the book is concerned with the application of the fundamentals of mechanical engineering to specific machine components. In practice, problems involving the design, analysis, or application of machine members can seldom be solved by applying the fundamentals alone. Also, there is seldom just one right answer. This second section of the book gives the engineer exposure with these types of problems. Each chapter in this section deals with design issues in particular types of mechanical devices - springs, gears, bearings, clutches, brakes, etc. The final chapter of the section is a case study of the first commercially successful automotive automatic transmission, drawing on the knowledge of all of the individual devices studied in previous chapters of part two.

The updates to this fourth edition versus the third edition are:
* Chapter 1 has some new material including a hierarchy of design that sets design guidelines for minimizing risk as well as the documenting of a new product.
* Section 3.14 "Engineering Material Selection Process" is new material.
* Section 6.4 on "Fracture Mechanics - Applications" has been expanded.
* There are two new sections in Chapter 8 entitled "Fatigue Crack Growth" and "General Approach for Fatigue Design".
* There is more reference to various websites in this edition.
* Both the example and homework problems have been revised.

The third and previous edition of this book is only two years older than the current fourth edition, and actually contains about 100 pages more material than the fourth edition. Given the high cost of the fourth edition, and the fact that the third edition can be obtained used rather inexpensively, you might want to consider getting the third edition of this book if you do not consider this list of new features essential. A good companion to this book is the latest edition of "Machinery's Handbook" since it has equations and tables in a very concise format. However, I highly recommend you get a copy of either the third or fourth edition of this book too. It has a wealth of material on mechanical design, and if you are already a mechanical engineer, it will make you fall in love with the discipline all over again.

The first edition was a required college text, but I kept using it so much the cover wore out! The chapters are well laid out, and the sample problems really bring the main concepts into the real world. Every colleague to whom I have shown this book has been impressed.

This book was required for my first course in mechanical design and I've kept is as a desk reference at work. The book is well organized and practical. The techniques outlined in the later chapters apply good design techniques and provide usable information for machine component designers. I recommend this book to anyone requiring a mechanical reference.

The book covers a broad range of problems in machine design but lacks clear explanations and citations. Often times in sample problems the author's solution skips crucial steps or fails to cite information. The section on fasteners is lacking as well. It also does not mention AN or NAS fasteners. Too many coeficients are taken blindy from charts which are not cited. This makes the problems in the book little more than blind "plug & chug" type problems. One might expect this from a first or second edition high school book, but not a fourth edition college text.

Generally, books with this title are composed of two parts: theory and machine application. The two parts are written in very different manners.

This book is very good in theory part. It could be used for a quick reference at your workplace. It contains various topics from solid mechanics and explains them clearly.

However, the machine application part is not as good as the theory part. The largest problem is that new concepts are introduced in the problems, not in the text. Although examples are given, they only give very basic plug-and-chug problems. You will find yourself FOOLED when you try to solve the practice problems. I learned more from the solutions manual than from the text. The book keeps doing that in most chapters of machine application part.

The result of my review are as follows:

1.excellent presentation of animated gear simulation by the United States Air Force Academy
2.Good examples at Student Solutions
3.Containing very useful informations about machine design

My comments

1. The type of copies in the acrobat files are not so clear, a little blard.
2. Working button shall be added in the table of contentents in the acrobat files to access the topics you wanted easily since this file contains more than a hundred pages.
3. All equations should be given a derivation; if it belongs to other references, please type the references below the equation

This book explains in detail how a good design should be carried out, is easy to read and to use. It really makes engineers happy they chose to be what we are!

Book came in good condition and arrived exactly as expected. There was a missing cd but it's not important, so it didn't bother me at all.

This is a good reference / text book for a Mechanical engineer with formal training. The book covers a broad range of engineering design applications and problems and moves quickly between chapters. Do not buy this book if you do not have any formal training or classes in fundamental Engineering: static's, dynamics, material science, etc. This is not a step by step book. This is a typical college text book that can also be used as a reference book. The author presents information as if your were in a classroom environment; namely a few steps, and then jumps to the solution; as you can clearly see the solution is ???. If you are looking just for a pure reference book, purchase Machinery's Handbook instead, 2700 pages plus by Industrial Press, Inc. If you can not find it in this book, just give up..

This book does great with showing the easier way to do stress and strain analysis.