1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
18 minutes of quality melodic doomy death metal., July 3, 2006
This review is from: For Funerals to Come (Audio CD)
A couple of years after their debut full-length album, Katatonia returned with this 4 track EP. With a running time of only 18 minutes, this may at first appear to be unworthy of your attention, yet you would be missing out on some really great early period Katatonia if you pass it up. None of the material was available on any other release until the "Brave Yester Days" compilation in 2004 which contains it in its entirety. So there's no reason to hunt down the out of print slipcase edition unless you're a Katatonia completist like myself.
Although it states in the slipcase that they have a new member named Guillaume Le Huche, it is in fact the same bassist as on "Dance of December Souls" (he was named Israphel Wing on that release), so the line-up is unchanged. This would be the last release that Renkse would sing in an aggressive style. The next album would contain the awesome vocals of Mikael Akerfeldt, before Renkse would return to the duty with the clean vocal style that still remains today.
This EP is more appropriately compared to what came before it than what would follow, as it's sound is more in line with "Dance of December Souls" than "Brave Murder Day". Doom / death metal with more of an emphasis on melody than previous releases. 8 minute opener "Funeral Wedding" is the standout track, containing stunning melodies throughout, a double bass drum/guitar interlude and a fantastic vocal performance. "Shades of Emerald Fields" is a fairly rocking track which once again contains a lot of variety and a whole selection of riffs and melodies to keep things interesting. That's something that really stands out when listening to the early Katatonia albums. Each song contains so many separate little sections while still holding a constant them and remaining coherent throughout. The remaining 4 minutes contain "For Funerals to Come" (an acoustic piece with haunting clean vocals) and finally, "Epistel" (a mix of distortion and rather frightening reversed screaming!). Overall, I find this release to be short but sweet and well worth checking out for fans of their early style.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4.0 out of 5 stars
Classic old era Katatonia, April 17, 2006
This review is from: For Funerals to Come (Audio CD)
Originally released in 1994 and now out of print, on this release we're treated to a more brutal-sounding Katatonia contrasting greatly with their current manifestation. During this time the band was modifying its style slightly with each release, and this EP is no exception. Highlights like the doom metal opus "Funeral Wedding" and the somber, growl-free title track show a band that knew how to experiment back during what Katatonia calls its "old era". Even the brief closing track, "Epistel" is worth an occasional listen for fans of industrial noise and backmasking, which are both contained here.
These days you're more likely to find this EP paired up with the later release, Brave Murder Day. Some pressings even include a third release, Sounds of Decay, on the same disc. My advice, however, is to try to find an original, stand-alone pressing of this release, particularly the highly elusive version bearing Katatonia's logo in a white font.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No