3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Good but not great, July 6, 2000
By A Customer
I really hated that Heaven would not continue the narration spot as in the other three books. Although I know that is the formula V.C. uses I still don't like it much. You become so attached to the Heaven in the first three books that changing point of view to the daughter's side is kinda weird. I have to admit that in the Cutler series when the same thing happened in the fourth book I enjoyed much more. I think the only reason I didn't enjoy this one as much was because there wasn't much action. And all the mysteries in the book you already new the answers from the previous books. It was fun though to see your old favorite characeters progress. Like Aunt Fanny wasn't so immature anymore and Tony Tatterton really was a sick demented guy. I have to admit I always felt a little sorry for Tony in the past few books but not in this one. Definitely read it if you are intrested in the Casteel family saga but the first three Heaven books are much better.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Fourth Book in the Casteel Series, May 1, 2002
By A Customer
This review is from: GATES OF PARADISE (Mass Market Paperback)
Starting 17 years after "Fallen Hearts" ended, "Gates of Paradise" follows Heaven Leigh Casteel's teenage daughter, Annie Stonewall, as she copes with the death of her parents and her new disability. Like many of V. C. Andrews' heroines, Annie has one forbidden love--her half-brother, Luke Casteel, Jr--, who she misses terribly when she is sent to her grandfather's mansion (Farthinggale Manor) in Boston to recuperate. While she's there, Annie is not only mistreated by her nurse (Mrs. Broadfield), but by her delusional grandfather, Tony Tatterton, who mistakes her for Heaven and Leigh quite often. Because she's isolated from most of her family, Annie has no one to really turn to, except a mysterious older man who calls himself Timothy Brothers and lives in the cottage nearby.
"Gates of Paradise" is the only disappointing book in this series; the other four books--"Heaven" (#1), "Dark Angel" (#2), "Fallen Hearts" (#3), and "Web of Dreams" (#5)--are all terrific. I had a hard time liking Annie's character; she was too whiny and weak and nothing like her mother, Heaven, who was quite a fighter. Plus, the plot was a little dull with Annie confined to her room or her wheelchair. There weren't a lot of new secrets revealed either; most of them had been uncovered in the previous three books. So, what exactly was the point of this book?
Despite "Gates of Paradise", the Casteel series is still one of my favorite series by V. C. Andrews. And if you want to find out how all of this confusion and incest began, then don't miss the fifth and final book: "Web of Dreams".
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Another good read, September 30, 2008
While not as good as the other Casteel books (possibly because it was finished by Andrew Neiderman after VCAndrew's death), this book is still a very good read. The ending felt a bit rushed, but if you read the first three Heaven books and want to see how the saga closes, pick up this book. There's not as much action in here since it's supposed to be the end of the Casteel saga so the ending might feel cliched and I definitely think it could have been better, but c'est la vie. 4 out of five stars isn't so bad, after all.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No