Most Helpful Customer Reviews
18 of 18 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Powers' American tragic vision ranks with Fitzgerald's, August 3, 1999
By A Customer
This review is from: Gain (Paperback)
Serious American novelists are compelled to confront certain questions: what is right about America? What is wrong with us? A select company of writers are distinguished by their ability to recognize that the answers to these questions are virtually identical. I am thinking about Dreiser, Fitzgerald and, now, Richard Powers. In Gain, Powers tells two stories in one, one historical and one contemporary: the first tells of the seemingly irresistible rise of Clare, a multi-national corporation; and the second examines the life of a working mother afflicted with ovarian cancer -- a disease evidently caused by chemicals released by Clare's manufacturing processes. The book reads somewhat like a novelistic rendering of Hardy's poem "The Convergence of the Twain." Like the iceberg and liner in Hardy's work, heroine and corporation are on a collision course plotted by human vanity and outraged nature. As in the very best of classical tragedies, the action seems both sadly unnecessary and starkly inevitable. As the soap-selling business of the Clare brothers gathers momentum, one feels both the thrill of its financial triumph and the horror of the humam cost its growth exacts. In this novel, the conditions of American society enable characters to conceive great visions and to pursue them with courage and enthusiasm. At the end of the day, however, they cannot escape either their mortality or the prosaic, banal truth of their existence. Did so many brave, intelligent people labor and die just so that the heroine's teenage son can play video wargames in the comfort of a suburban bedroom? It is troubling, Powers suggests, that all our hopes and strivings should take us no further than this. Even-handedly, however, Powers shows us the benefits of industry as well as its dark side. Also deeply impressive is the sheer knowledge conveyed by this novel, ranging from insights into Whitman's "Crossing Brooklyn Ferry" to informed commentary on the process of making a bar of soap. While some readers may grow impatient with Powers' erudition, I found it fascinating to be in the presence of a poet who is also a technician. Gain is linked in my mind with the tragic quest of Gatsby and the life and death of Clyde Griffiths. Like Fitzgerald's novel and Dreiser's, it probes the core of the American Dream -- a dream that irresistibly calls its followers onward, a dream too mighty to escape but too fantastic to fully achieve. The book is a powerful jeremiad against those who gain the world and lose their souls, but it also acknowledges that this kind of self-destruction may be inherent in the human, or at least the American, condition. Gain is one of the very best business novels I have read. In my view, it is one of the best American books of the last 25 years, maybe longer.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
11 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Simply a Fantastic Novel, June 7, 2000
This review is from: Gain (Paperback)
I was looking for something different when I picked up "Gain", something other than the shopworn "coming of age" literary novel I seem to keep reading over and over, and boy did I find it. Skeptical at first (I'm not a fan of either business or terminal illness books) "Gain" soon won me over with Powers solid writing (piled a little thick in places but overall a pleasure) and the interwoven tales of Clare Soap and the local woman who contracts ovarian cancer allegedly from its products or factory. Powers provides an interesting thumbnail sketch of the rise of the corporation in America, one that is light yet informative and, for the most part, accurate. This part of the book is dry in places but given the subject matter, he has to be given credit for breathing as much life as possible into an inanimate object. His treatment of Laura and her family was warm and resonating, however. Too much of her struggles probably would have been too much for me to handle but by breaking it up the way he did, he made her tragic tale somewhat easier to take than would otherwise have been the case. Towards the end I started wondering how this was going to wrap up. I was anticipating the obvious: the big courtroom trial, verdict and either vindication or pathos but what Powers did instead was brilliant. I won't divulge it here but his ending brought both narratives together in a way that was completely unexpected. I don't know what novel the people who criticized it for being leftist and "anti-corporation" were reading, but it certainly wasn't "Gain". Rather, I felt that Powers showed us all sides of the corporation-the good, the bad and the ugly, and left it to us to draw our own conclusions. The ending in particular highlights the point that anyone who derides corporate America as simply being downright evil just doesn't get it. Corporations provide much of what is wonderful in the world. But they do it at a cost. Whether that cost creates evils which outweigh everything else is something each of us has to deal with on our own.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
12 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
People want everything. Thats their problem., September 18, 2000
This review is from: Gain (Paperback)
I have not read all of the books that Mr. Powers has written. This is the fourth, and while the writing is not as complex, with each subsequent phrase attempting to make its predecessor seem inferior, he has created a book that begins with two stories widely separated in time and brings them together with final pages that are emotionally devastating. The wealth of knowledge this Author is known for is again evident in "Gain". The difference this time is that he shows an understanding of the human condition, its pain and its suffering as though he experiences the trauma as he writes. He writes about an experience we all will face, and it reads as though it is documented fact, not some mystic farce substituted for weak writing that lacks the skill that Mr. Powers has. His writing does not read as opinion, it feels as though you are reading the truth, that you are being told by someone who knows, and not just an authority on the topic, an articulate dandified product of academe, an erudite poser. A man and his wife arrive in Boston. Over a century later the son of another woman, working across the river in Cambridge, will take the money from a legal outcome that is a direct result of that first man's arrival, and likely set in motion events that are orders of magnitude more powerful. It could be argued that the moment the first man decided to emigrate, the countless number of steps, the cascade of effects were irrevocably put in motion. This tale could be dressed up as a form of Chaos Theory, the Butterfly in China whose delicate movements cause the East Coast of the US to be flooded. Mr. Powers does not need a curtain that wrapped the city of the Oz Wizard to conceal what he was unable to do. If Mr. powers were a magician, he could conjure all that illusionists do. Rolling up his sleeves would be meaningless, as he would require none. Mr. Powers has demonstrated he can write at any level of complexity, on subjects that only token numbers of people can get their minds around. In this work he tells a story that we all have heard countless times. However this is the first time we have heard him tell it, and the similarities are almost nil. The real world is not black and white, and neither is this writer's prose. The quote that is the title of my comments is spoken at a moment, and by a person that will demonstrate how powerful a simple statement can be. But this is a Richard Powers' book, where even a simple declarative sentence is unbounded. An incredible Author, and I have yet to read the book that almost all reviewers say is his best.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|