4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Groundbreaking research & analysis, August 1, 2003
This review is from: Gaitanismo, Left Liberalism, and Popular Mobilization in Colombia (Hardcover)
Colombia is starting to get glaring academic attention. It is well-deserved and overdue. To this end, "Gaitanismo, Left Liberalism, and Popular Mobilization in Colombia," by W. John Green dares to study a controversial populist movement. His work is groundbreaking and his analysis in some cases exceeds that of highly regarded historians Richard Sharpless and Herbert Braun.
Jorge Eliecer Gaitan is arguably the most important politician in the history of Colombia. Green dedicates a decade to examine the life of Gaitan...the sire of the Gaitanista movement. However, in the words of the author, "this study...is more about Gaitanismo and the left-Liberal political culture from which it sprang than about Gaitan per se." Gaitan is the authentic defender of working and undervalued classes and a man who always diligently escaped the stain of official corruption and scandal.
In a nutshell, Gaitanismo was the first independent, mass-based, popularly oriented mobilization of its magnitude in Colombian history. Green tracks Gaitan's career from the Colombian Congress, to the Senate, to the Ministry of Labor, to the Mayor of Bogota, to Minister of Education and finally to the leading presidential candidate in the nation at the time of his mysterious assassination on April 9, 1948.
Green starts by digging into Colombia's past and exposing the wide historical divisions in the Liberal Party. He also pulls no punches and provides an excellent documentation of Colombia's elite-dominated political system. Unfortunately, according to Green, "for all its political vigor, the system was prone to domination by powerful groups and individuals...given to arbitrary decisions and less than democratic procedures."
The author also dedicates much time to the many clashes Gaitan had with his bitter political enemy Laureano Gomez, the dominant power in the Colombian Conservative Party. For the most part Conservative Party elites and even some members of the Liberal Party hated Gaitan and "exhibited a near universal mixture of fear, anger and loathing," Green writes. According to the author, to Gomez "the only route to salvation was the Roman Catholic Church, he was antagonistic to all breeds of Liberalism and insisted that those who disagreed were not only wrong but evil." Eventually many Colombians end up despising Gomez for his heavy sympathizing with Italian Fascism and German National Socialism before and during World War II.
Green admirably concludes that "the allure of Gaitanism sometimes seems unworldly." This book is comprehensive and well-balanced. And carefully explains why the Colombian oligarchy unleashed a brutal counter-revolution to eliminate the political
call for social and land reforms immediately after the assassination of Gaitan.
Bert Ruiz
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No