Most Helpful Customer Reviews
20 of 21 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The Kids Are All Right, May 25, 2007
The Edward R. Murrow High School in Brooklyn has been a successful progressive school, whether despite or because of its mixture of Puerto Rican and black students along with immigrants from Poland, Lithuania, and Russia. It has been a radical experiment in public education, allowing pupils to skip classes and to make up their own schedules, curricula, or independent study projects. There has been a high level of student graduation and subsequent enrollment in college. The school might now be succumbing to No Child Left Behind mediocrity because it is being forced to admit students who are refugees from neighboring schools that have been closed due to failing their evaluations, but one of its brightest successes has been its chess team. The team won its first NYC championship in 1989 and has gone on to national championships. This meant that they were up against lots of other schools with teams that could afford tutors or chess camps during the summers. _The Kings of New York: A Year Among the Geeks, Oddballs, and Geniuses Who Make Up America's Top High School Chess Team_ (Gotham Books) thus has the dependable appeal of a David vs. Goliath story, as sportswriter Michael Weinreb followed the striving, scrappy students while they aimed toward another national championship. Though the book conveys excitement in the competition, as any sports book ought to, it is most rewarding in its picture of awkward teens being able to fasten onto something meaningful before turning into adults.
The Murrow team is the brainchild of Eliot Weiss, a former hockey player, ski instructor, beer vendor, and taxi driver who more than anything else wanted to be a math teacher. He does some coaching and teaching, but plenty of his students are far better players than he is. He works at organizing trips to tournaments, and a lot of what he does is drumming up money for the travel and for entry fees and for pizza to recharge the players. The kids are the heart of the book. Weinreb spends some pages on each of the main players, telling about their backgrounds and families. There is Oscar Santana, a Puerto Rican prodigy who is a whiz at chess but can't focus on his schoolwork. He does, however, bring home a straight A report card. Unfortunately, he did so by hacking the Board of Education computer and boosting his grades. Oscar brings home chess trophies so regularly that his family can't display them; they started storing them in garbage bags, and then started throwing them away. Also winning trophies is Alex Lenderman, a little Russian émigré, the second-highest rated 15-year-old chess player in America, but he knows that big trophies are just something else to lug through the subway system. What Alex, and the others, really want is to win some money, which they can do in a small way through tournament prizes, and in a larger way though wagering on games, often "blitz" chess played in lightning-fast games timed by a chess clock set to three minutes or even one minute. Alex's foe is blond Lithuanian Sal Bercys; the two players dislike each other but have mutual respect. When they are pitted against each other in tournaments, they choose to play out staged (and not strictly legal) draw games, but afterwards go at each other seriously in blitz versions. Sal grows throughout the book, becoming a stronger player by accepting his weaknesses. There are plenty of other supporting characters, and like the main ones, they wear baggy and unsupported pants, they love hip hop music, they can't figure out girls, they can't get enough pizza , or they keep ear buds firmly in place at all times.
As Weinreb asks, what is the point of these kids continuing to play an infuriating and exacting game, when they get almost no recognition, especially compared to kids who win spelling bees or even hot-dog-eating contests? The "notion of chess as a charity, as an educational tool, as a cultural equalizer in underprivileged neighborhoods" is a relatively new one, and holds considerable potential for social change. About a kid named Shawn who plays brilliant blitz chess but can't display energy for much of anything else, a teacher asks, "Where would Shawn be _without_ chess? What would his life be like then?" And maybe some of them are going to get a sort of living from the game, but more realistically they might get benefits like scholarships, so there must be some value to the endeavor. Weinreb, however, quotes a chess instructor who points out that they already have gotten the value, in becoming mentally tougher, more creative, more acute at solving problems: "The benefit will last the rest of their lives." They live in a strange world of their own, and don't worry if you don't know about chess, for it is all explained at a layman's level here and requires no previous expertise. Weinreb's gift is that he has been able to invite us into that world and make us care about the oddballs that live there.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
14 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Journalism at its Finest!, May 24, 2007
When I received a review copy of this book I will admit I was nervous of a couple things. First, there were some odd reviews here at Amazon that mentioned negativity and second I had to wonder between Waitzkin's 'Searching For Bobby Fischer' and Sawaski's novel 'The Chess Team' could the author bring me something new and different about scholastic chess. Weinreb really had his work cut out for him when I openend the book. In the end though, he met or exceeded all of my expectations and comes out with a rating of 5 stars! I'm not sure where the negativity originated, posssibly rivals of Murrow (the school depicted in the book) or what not, but Weinreb is clearly a darn good writer. There were a couple of typos in the manuscript, however, certainly nothing that blocked the flow or anything like that. His writing is clear, concise and he has an entertaining voice. The book was highly original. Nobody has ever followed a high school chess team before. Weinreb not only follows the team on chess tournaments, he digs in deep. He tells about the school and all the people around the school. Further, he tells about the chess world these kids are involved in and many of the figures and personalities it accompanies as well. He explains things that may not be clear to newcomers and he gives a solid history of what has happened to not just the players, but for scholastic chess in general. I have been a scholastic chess player and chess coach for almost three decades of my life and even I learned a thing or two about Murrow's process. The only tick I had with the book was some of the profanity that was used. Although it was done tastefully, and is correct journalism and Weinreb did his job keeping things 'real' ... This is a very minor opinion, but I just wasn't sure it should have been in the book because we're dealing with minors in general. In all though, Weinreb did an outstanding job with this book and I give it my full recommendation. If you have any attraction to scholastic chess whatsoever, then you will enjoy reading this book. I would not be surprised if this book won some sort of journalism award.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
16 of 18 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
This is not a book about chess, May 6, 2007
This is not a book about chess; this is a book about a teacher, a mild obsession, the impact of a profound interest on a city school, and how all of that can come together to make a huge difference.
It is also a prime example of how good writing can take an interesting story and turn it into a gripping book. This is the Stand and Deliver of board games, and it is great fun (especially if you like chess and/or you are from Brooklyn, and/or you grew up there). I had a great time reading it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
![[Start the discussion]](http://g-ecx.images-amazon.com/images/G/01/x-locale/communities/discussion_boards/start-new-discussion-sec._V192250339_.gif){kind=small}
