Customer Reviews

Game Theory [Vinyl]

5 star:		(62)
4 star:		(16)
3 star:		(4)
2 star:		(3)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

The Roots (Black Thought (MC), ?uestlove (Drums), Hub (Bass), Kamal (Keyboards), Knuckles (Percussion), and Captain Kirk (Guitar)) keep things moving delivering their seventh studio album "Game Theory" (2006). Former member Malik B returns for this release appearing on three tracks. Fellow Philadelphia native Peedi Peedi (AKA Peedi Crack formerly of State Property) appears on one track, and it is rumored he will be joining the Roots. Overall this album is laced with darker production and has the Root's talking about more serious issues - like politics, war and the state of the world. The album opens with "Dillatastic Vol Won(derful)" a short instrumental and ends with "Can't Stop This", both a tribute to the late great producer J Dilla aka Jay Dee (R.I.P.). The eight-minute closing track is my favourite on this album, Black Thought rhymes over J Dilla's excellent production providing an outstanding track. The album's first full-length track is "False Media" an ominous sounding track; laced with a dark chorus (Wadud Ahmad), Black Thoughts rhymes are on point. Black Thought reunites with Malik B and both flow fast over the title track "Game Theory". The first single "Don't Feel Right" is a powerful cut, which has Black Thought talking about the problems of the world. The production to "In The Music" is deadly and the highlight of that cut for me, Black Thought continues to drop thought provoking rhymes backed by some words from Wadud Ahmad on "Take It There". John-John provides the chorus to the more laidback sounding "Baby", and the three MC's who have rhymed for the Roots over the years - Black Thought, Malik B and Dice Raw triple tag team "Here I Come". Black Thought, Peedi Peedi rep Philadelphia and talk about their beginnings backed by some feel good production on "Long Time". Black Thought reflects on years past, broken friendships and regrets on the exceptional "Clock With No Hands" backed by some soulful singing from Mercedes Martinez. The Roots shine again with "Atonement" feat. Jack Davey (Brook D'Leu and Jack Davey), Brook's chorus is outstanding. Black Thought never fails to impress me, seems like he gets better and better as time goes by like good wine. The Root's Crew provides outstanding instrumentals and production - I would love to hear them live. Short, memorable & potent "Game Theory" is another keeper for Root's fans.

I normally try to listen to a record a good five to ten times before I review it, but I'm only on my second listen & I just have to express how impressive this album is. It Starts off with a very quick instrumental intro with a little vocal sample, but quickly segues into the scathing "False Media" (2) and one has to wonder if the press is gonna hate on this album just because of this song. The title track follows and is so live you can't help but scrunch up your brow and nod your head. The lead single "Don't Feel Right" on it's own does not stand out as an amazing track but in context of the rest of the album and where it is placed in the order of tracks it feels so right. Musically Hub, Kamal, Kirk & Knuckles play their part perfectly while ?uest ties it all together like only he can. This is by far one of the most musical LP's the Roots have dropped not only in a minute, but throughout their whole career. You can hear influences of Funkadelic, Prince, Miles Davis, Shuggie Otis, etc. throughout and it's completed with the one man who is always forgotten when it comes to lists of great emcees: Black Thought. Thought steps up and knocks one out the park on this release, what may be his best yet. He delivers autobiographical tales about the streets of Philly, he delivers social commentary, and he gets his braggadocio on. This is his testament to all the haters who think the Roots are great because of the band. They are great because of the band and Black Thought is the integral part of that band that puts them a step above. Malik B also makes his triumphant return to the group that he was an original member of and he sounds so fresh. Its perfect hearing him and BT rip it together like any classic rhyming duo, and they haven't missed a step. This album is dark and moody and will probably receive criticism for that, but where would you be artistically after leaving your label of ten years, dropping possibly your worst album ever, and then being told by one of the greatest to ever pick up a mic (who just happens to be your new boss) "Do not embarrass me." Jay has nothing to fear as he will forever be remembered as the man who brought the Roots to a major label and let them release "their" music.

Game Theory is The Roots' 7th album of original material, and although the music remains as dope as it was at the beginning, their sound has greatly evolved and matured. Game Theory is their darkest, most mature, and most politically charged album' production wise, and lyric wise.

The production on this album is definately a highlight. The Roots produce most of the album themselves, but James Poyser, Khari Mateen, Tahir Jamal, Richard Nichols, Owen Biddle, Kevin Hansen, J. Dilla and others help out. J. Dilla (RIP) produced the 28 second intro, as well as the final track, 'Can't Stop This', which is a tribute to Dilla that uses the beat 'Time: The Donut Of The Heart' from Dilla's incredible instrumental album 'Donuts'. The rest of the album has a large production range from extremely chill ('Atonement'), to as hype as a Roots song gets ('Here I Come'), but most of them fall comfortably in the middle. As I stated earlier, this album has the darkest production of any Roots album. This goes perfectly with the lyrical content of the album, as well as provides a great tone throughout the album.

While the production on Game Theory is top notch, even for Roots standards, Black Thought is really the shining point of this album. Game Theory is Black Thought's best album lyrically yet. The social & political consciousness of the album, and how it's presented is extremely impactful and makes for an interesting, and very hard hitting album. The album also has some noteworthy guest apperances, with easily the most noteworthy being the return of Malik B. Malik is only featured on 3 tracks, but he drops dope verses on all 3 tracks, which are 3 of the best tracks of the album. I really hope that Malik, who was dismissed from the group as a result of drug problems, will play a more prominant role on the next Roots album, because he has been such a great compliment to Black Thought in the past.

Game Theory is The Roots' best album since 1999 ('Things Fall Apart'; which I also consider a classic), and is probably the best album of 2006 (only rivaled by J. Dilla's 'Donuts'). This album is definately a sign of good things to come for The Roots on Def Jam, and should be the beginning of a great relationship.

Top 5 Songs (In Order):

1. Can't Stop This - J. Dilla tribute song over 'Time: The Donut Of The Heart' from Dilla's 'Donuts'. Easily one of the best songs of 2006 so far. R.I.P.

2. Game Theory (Featuring Malik B) - Malik B returns with a nice verse on just an overall GREAT track.

3. Here I Come (Featuring Malik B & Dice Raw) - The 3 best MCs of the 90s Roots crew reunite for a great track over one of the best beats on the album.

4. Don't Feel Right (Featuring Maimouna Youssef) - Another overall dope track.

5. In The Music (Featuring Malik B & Porn) - Some great production, as well as the 3rd dope verse on the album from Malik B.

Worst Track:

Clock With No Hands (Featuring Mercedes Martinez) - My least favorite beat on the album, and although it's a good song, it's kind of boring.

Lyrics/Substance/Subject Matter - 10/10
Flow/Delivery - 9.5/10
Production - 9.5/10
Overall Feel - 10/10

Guest Apperances - Malik B, Maimouna Youssef, Porn, Wadud Ahmad, John-John, Dice Raw, Peedi Peedi, Bunny Sigler, Mercedes Martinez & Jack Davey - 8/10 - Guests contribute some great hooks and nice compliment verses.
Overall Rating - 10/10 - Another classic from The Legendary Roots Crew. If you have any interest in hip hop (and I dont mean Young Joc), this is a must have.

Finally. The Roots are back. On their first studio release since Tipping Point, they make a lot of changes but manage to remain the same (if that makes any sense). Gone are most of the upbeat, fun joints that get you amped. They're replaced by dark, almost cinematic production courtesy of The Roots, J Dilla, and Kamal (on the keys). Another change is the lyrical content. Black Thought seems to be on more of a conscious tip instead of the normal smashing of emcees and flexing of lyrical muscles. Don't get me wrong, he still rips, but he's sprinkling more message than usual this time around. Also, I'm one of the few people that sorely missed Malik B., so I bugged out when I heard him step in on the outstanding title track, "Game Theory". He still rhymes with the same presence and skill that he showed before his departure (be sure to check his solo LP too....it's dope) and he shows up on two more great tracks -- "In The Music" and the bangin' "Here I Come" feat. Dice Raw. Not only is M-Illitant back, but Dice Raw seems to have regained his passion and Peedi Peedi (rumored to be joining the group) aka Peedi Crack of State Property steps up his game and drops a dope verse on the bangin' "Long Time". I always knew Peedi could spit, I was just waiting for him to actually say something and he does it on this album. Guests include those already mentioned along with Maimouna Youssef, Wadud Ahmad, Porn, Bunny Sigler, John John, Mercedes Martinez, and Jack Davey and they all shine. The late Jay Dee aka J Dilla makes his posthumous impact on the brief Dillatastic Vol Won(derful) which he "oversees" and the excellent "Can't Stop This" (which the beat for this song can also be found on his Donuts LP).

As far as flaws, I can't think of any. The newer, darker sound works well for them, so no beef there. If I had to find a beef, it would be the fact that The Roots didn't include a hidden track (which I think is a first for them....but don't quote me). Maybe it's one of the changes that comes with rolling with the Carter Administration/Def Jam. Who knows. My complaint is a very minor one though.

Game Theory Is the most complete, well rounded release from the Roots since Things Fall Apart. Not only did BT rip every track while Malik B. returned to do three tracks, but the production bangs nonstop. The Roots' Def Jam debut is a home run. They finally have the handcuffs removed and are allowed to release their vision upon the masses -- and they've never sounded better. I recommend adding this to your record collection asap. Satisfaction is definitely guaranteed.

Standout Tracks: Clock With No Hands feat. Mercedes Martinez of The Jazzyfatnastees, Long Time feat. Peedi Peedi & Bunny Sigler, In The Music feat. Malik B. & Porn, Game Theory feat. Malik B., Don't Feel Right feat. Maimouna Youssef, Here I Come feat. Dice Raw & Malik B., False Media, and Can't Stop This (My Favorite)

Over the past decade or so The Roots have staked out a pretty nice niche as one of the few hip-hop acts with significant appeal to non-fans of the genre, and Game Theory certainly won't disappoint fans of past efforts. Once again striking a near-perfect balance of energy, creativity, and intelligence, Game Theory continues with the progressive-minded, R&B/ soul influenced approach that made 2002's Phrenology a classic, but the aggression level has seemingly been upped a few notches this time around. After a brief intro, the album declares its intentions immediately with the disaffected manifesto of False Media, a shot fired right across the bow of mainstream American society. From there, Game Theory continues in the same vein, specializing in angry, gloomy tales of urban decay, led by the furious raps of Black Thought and the driving, polyrhythmic drumwork of ?uestlove.

Game Theory is at its best when it's at its most confrontational and intense, which makes it somewhat of a letdown when the album settles into a series of more laid-back, R&B oriented tracks in its final third. That said, the seven tracks after the intro pack about as much brilliance into a twenty-minute stretch as you're going to find, as they're everything most mainstream hip-hop isn't--intricate, clever, and brutally honest. Be it the frenetic time signatures and ultra-anthemic chorus of the hard-charging Here I Come, the clanging, hard-edged beats of the ominous In the Music, or the fast-paced, headbanging fury of the title track (my pick for song of the year), the best moments of Game Theory are among the most memorable of 2006 in any genre. Much of Game Theory is the sound of people who have faced the kind of adversity that's brought down numerous others, and are still here to talk about it. It's just too bad that in a musical climate where suburban children of privilege can be taken seriously for whining about their feelings, there aren't more people willing to listen.

mistermaxxxx (aka r kelly's wife) has a grudge with the roots because they haven't made a tribute album to r kelly yet. anyway, on to the album.

i've been a fan since illidelph halflife. while their last two albums were a tad inconsistant, this brings back memories of things fall apart and illidelph. though not as classic as those albums, it is up there with them. my only problems with the album:

atonement is kinda of a filler track to me. not bad, but not great.

and livin in a new world is WAYYYY to short.

if you love hip hop, chances are you're gonna love this album. but don't take my word for it, take damn near every reviewers'.

If The Clash are the only band that matters, The Roots are the only rap group that matters. Such a novel approach to rap, having live instrumentation, took a while to find an audience, myself not discovering them until around Illadelph Halflife, and are now the go to band for any rapper who want to put on a great live such as Jay-Z's legendary Unplugged, Eminem's performance at the Grammy's for Lose Yourself and they were the house band for last year's Hip Hop Honors. But as good as the band is at reinterpreting other's music, the band is at its best making their own music with Black Thought, possible the most underrated MC in the game today, handling the mike and The Roots are back to save hip-hop once again with Game Theory.

There was a lot of hoopla when The Roots signed with Def Jam with fans fearing that the group would be a watered down version of its former self. That complaint just never made sense because the group came from Geffin Records, not really an indie label. Now they move to a label deeply rooted in hip-hop with their new boss an old friend and collaborator, Jay-Z. At first listen, Game Theory is definitely a Roots album, in fact they may have went the other way from commercial success with more overtly political songs then previous album. If anything, Def Jam may have helped trim some of the fat. Let's face it, as great as their previous albums were, the back half of many of their albums were filled with eccentricities and could have been helped by trimming down to around forty-five minutes which is what Game Theory clocks in at.

As usual, the album starts of with a short keyboard heavy intro to set the mood before going before ?uestlove, quite possible this generation's greatest drummer, brings the sick beat as the anti-news outlets theme False Media. The song definitely sets the tone for the darker and angrier album. There are a few upbeat tracks with the party starter Don't Feel Right and the Big Daddy Kane feeling Here I Come. There is also cool, almost bohemian track Livin' in a New World which features a Strokes like chorus. The album is capped off with Can't Stop This, a touching tribute with sometime producer J Dilla, who produced two songs on this album, who succumbed to lupus after a three year battle. The tribute being on this album will ensure Dilla will never be forgotten.

There's a lot of praise for this album, so I'm not gonna go through track-by-track and break rehash everything that's already been said on Amazon. Short and to the point...this album, from open to close, is unbelievably creative, musically and lyrically sharp. To me, the best track is "Game Theory" (3rd track). You don't hear Black Thought's voice until about 40 seconds into the song, but he brings it with everything he's got. Thought rips the track for two verses and drops these memorable lines over a nasty beat: "Voted most unlikely to succeed/Cause my class was full of naysayers, cheaters and thieves" and then Malik B makes his first appearance on a Roots album since "Things Fall Apart"(?). Great album...like Thought says, "If you ain't got no paper then steal this CD." This is some transcendant hip hop...

Don't you just love it when your favorite artists keep surprising you over and over and over? Well, that's what the Legendary Illadeph Crew has done to me...again. After the near flawless 10 tracks that comprised '04's "The Tipping Point", I figured a change to a new label & the loss of a close friend and genius collaborator (R.I.P. J Dilla) the band would've had the wind knocked out of it's sails for a while, but if anything, 2 years of upheaval and transition have made them stronger. "Game Theory" is perfect. 12 tight tracks, 47 minutes and not a wasted note or lyric to be found. There's a refreshing brevity, speed and intensity in this music that makes it instantly addictive and few bands today are able to balance hip-hop, rock, soul and shades of techno as well as The Roots, without sounding forced or contrived. And YES, you will be smiling like a cheshire cat when you hear Malik B. back on board rhyming alongside Black Thought for the first time this century on the blazing title cut, and drooling WHILE YOU NOD YOUR HEAD, to the crisp new crack in ?uestlove's drums on "Don't Feel Right". The band stretches out into jazz-rock territory on the terrific "Long Time" and even gets in a nice nod to Radiohead on "Atonement".
This is my most eagerly anticipated release of the year and it does not disappoint. Another Classic.

This is so far the best and most important hip hop album of the year 2006...and it may be considered one of the hip hop classics for many years to come...Black Thought is the most underrated MC/lyricists out there!!! If you're a Hip Hop fan, you should have this album in your music collection.