Customer Reviews

Gamera Limited Edition Box Set

5 star:		(26)
4 star:		(9)
3 star:		(2)
2 star:		(2)
1 star:		(2)

 

 

It was only recently, to be honest, that I first learned who Gamera even was. Godzilla? Sure, I grew up on the guy... I've got the lunchbox, have taped the Godzilla's Rockin' New Year's Eve special many times and even saw the Andrew Lloyd Weber adaptation on Broadway during its woefully short run in 1994.

But now there's a NEW guardian of the universe? Why didn't anyone tell me?? Finally, someone did. Specifically, it was a co-worker from the main office of the Tokyo-based manufacturing company (it shall remain nameless) for which I have worked for the last 8 years. He was relocated to New York and has become a rather good friend.

Hunushi is a fantastic resource for all things Japanese. One of those is monster movies ("kaiju" as the genre is called in Japan), and I am also a big fan. Knowing this, Hunushi recommended to me the first Gamera film when it was released in English in 1997. Since then, I have been hooked and wanting more.

Why do I like this Gamera series so much? The special effects are AWESOME, and the dubbing is simply masterful. Forget everything that you thought you knew about dubbed dialogue, as that knowledge is now useless and outdated. The story lines are engaging, the characters are well developed. These are great movies, period.

When I heard that a box set of all three movies (Gamera: Guardian of the Universe, Gamera 2: Attack of Legion and Gamera 3: Revenge of Iris) was available, I jumped on it.

I thought I knew why I was buying this box set, but I had no idea at the time that its most entertaining feature was an as-yet-unknown-to-me DVD extra. Within the extras of the second film, Gamera 2, the English-language director has created an entirely new and hilarious version of that film dubbed almost entirely with "red neck" character voices.

This is an absolute stitch, but in no way did it offend my delicate "kaiju" sensibilities. Gamera remains completely untouched in this tongue-in-cheek version of the film. Only the human contingent, scurrying below, is made to look anything less than admirable. The bottom line is this: I have never laughed harder in my life (by the way, there is also a fantastic DVD extra on the 3rd disc but I'll let you discover that one on your own).

I hope you enjoy these films as much as I have. Thankfully, it looks like Japan's best kept "kaiju" secret has just been let out of the box!

I'm amazed by the story lines and special effects in these newer come-back movies of Gamera. The box set was purchased with Christmas money, and I'm glad I did so. Gamera began as low-budget giant monster movies in competition with Godzilla in about 1965. Some of the early films are pretty cheezy, though fun to watch. Kids especially seem to relate to the big turtle. My daughter likes him as much as Godzilla.

The new Gamera pictures carry on the idea that Gamera is here to protect earth, but the story lines are very mature compared to the original films, and the special effects are, at times, amazing. Every bit on a parr with the newer, new millenium Godzilla films of the past five years. The first film in the pack, "Gamera: Guardian of the Universe", was release in 1995, and the others followed about every two years. The origin of Gamera is reinvented here, and explained in a way that is a nice marriage of fantasy and science-fiction. In the first film, Gamara's heroic mythology is backed up by an ancient tablet that predicts a giant creature will rise to combat an horrific darkness. All evidence points to some sort of flesh eating creatures that nearly ate man to extinction in the time when Atlantis was still above water.

The second film, "Attack of Legion", is even better, with an even creepier creature and It's swarming spawn called "Legion" (from the Bible, no less) threatening earth's extiction yet again. The special effects are better in this film, and that's saying a lot, since the first movie was very well done.

I haven't watched the third movie, "Revenge of Iris" yet, but even if it turns out to be disappointing compared to the first two, it was still money worth spending.

All three pictures are presented in anamorphic widescreen, with language options of the original Japanese with English subtitles, or in dubbed English. The soundtracks are in Dolby digital 5.1. I really enjoyed watching the second film in the original Japanese, thus getting to hear the true emotions of the actors. There are a lot of nice extras included on the disks, so take some time to explore.

The movies themselves are excellent, but the subtitling is perhaps the worst professional work I've seen, especially with the first and third films. In the first, none of the Japanese on screen text is translated, despite the movie using a large number of things like newspaper headlines to provide information. The third is the worst by far, with a good 20% of it not being subtitled at all, and quite of few of the subtitles being mistranslated. It's an absolute shame, since these are great movies that deserve much better treatment.

Oldschool Gamera is definitely classic kaiju, it just tends to have some of the worst aspects of kaiju built into its roots: annoying little kids, illogical stories, bad set designs, and plots that seem just a skeleton to justify monster fights. Good kaiju, on the other hand, tends to have characters that the viewer can indentify with, a sense of being overwhelmed by the size of the battles, a desperation for survival, allegory to real world problems, and monsters that, though they may be large and scary, are somehow sympathetic at the same time.

That is what I like about this new trilogy. It takes one of the more ludicrous monsters, a large turtle that walks on its hind legs, eats fire and uses atomic jets to propel itself, and gives it as a good of a treatment as I have ever seen a kaiju receive.

The first one has an excellent story, and a great old school "King Kong" kind of feel to it. The second one, which seems to either be the favorite or the most hated depending on who you ask, takes the story a step up (in my opinion) and adds a level of desperation that somehow was lacking in the first one. The fight scenes and effects are improved, though the sense of adventure and human interaction is weakened and the almost add-on moral from the very end seems out of place. The last one is probably the best, and I feel it is such because the story line brings the monster-to-hero so epitomized in the original Gamera idea full circle.

The effects are excellent by kaiju standards (which are still lacking by what some people would want, but I loved them) and the storylines are still a little illogical. The new explanation for the origins is kind of better as far as making sense of the oddity that is Gamera, but not 100% satisfactory. The dubbing and the subbing are both excellent, and I love the fact that I can get wide-screened, well transferred dvds as opposed to the low quality ones with bad dubbing that are normally part of the genre. The features are not the best in the world, but were a nice addition (since I got the movies for the movies, the extras are just some additional icing).

Shusuke Kaneko's GAMERA Trilogy is the high mark of "kaiju eiga", or Japanese monster movies. While lacking even the budget of Toho's rival Godzilla, they compensate with inventive special effects and smart scripts by frequent Mamoru Oshii collaborator Kazunori Ito (Ghost in the Shell, Avalon, Patlabor). In an added twist, the films stand apart from the rest of their genre by subverting various cliches and showing a strong feminist bent--the main characters of all three films are smart, capable women, a trait that is magnified to a surprising degree in the apocalyptic final film. This progressive streak is typical of Kaneko's work, making him one of the most humanist of Japanese mainstream directors.

The first film, GAMERA: GUARDIAN OF THE UNIVERSE, is a fun, knowing throwback to the giant monster movies of the sixties--all bright primary colors, environmental messages and mystical backstories. It's good, silly entertainment, with some impressive anime-inspired visuals during the monster sequences, a memorable score by Ko Otani and plucky, likeable characters. The sequel, GAMERA 2, eschews the light-hearted tone of its predecessor and proves itself to be a well-crafted, occasionally violent action film. Gamera's opponent this time around is an alien insect with a refreshingly well-developed and plausible modus operandi. GAMERA 3 is the real achievement of the trilogy, though: the dark, complex script by Ito (by this point, the films have amassed a quite involved little mythology), the strong female cast, superb special effects (no, really) and Ôtani's excellent score make this probably the best Japanese special effects film ever made. Fans of H.P. Lovecraft should also enjoy Iris itself--after collaborating on the anthology film NECRONOMICON, Kaneko and Ito here conjure up their answer to Cthulhu, complete with it's own cult followers and doomsday prophecies.

After a long year of waiting, Mill Creek has finally completed the trilogy by releasing Gamera 3 on blu-ray--and surprise, surprise, they screwed up, big time. (The trilogy pack consists of a nice slipcover and the two discs--the first disc being the same solid double feature disc released last year. As such, the rest of this review will focus on the new GAMERA 3 disc.)

First, the good: the transfer is excellent. Crisp, sharp and with a beautiful 'pop' in many of the climactic scenes of destruction. Grain is intact and looks nice, and while there is some noise and occasional banding, this is overall the best this film will probably ever look. The audio is likewise excellent, a nice DTS-HD Master Audio mix. As for extras, there are nearly three hours worth, representing the whole trilogy--though almost half of the extras are comprised of fly-on-the-wall on set featurettes for Gamera 2. All of these are ported over from the Japanese laserdisc releases, and while not as substantive as the extras that were on ADV's DVD releases, they are still an interesting look at how the trilogy was made.

Now the bad, and it is very bad indeed: the subtitles are atrocious, and that's putting it mildly. We are talking cheap, Hong Kong bootleg DVD bad. I kid you not--literally every other line is either mis-subtitled or not even subtitled at all. Roughly 35% of the dialogue is missing. Mill Creek had a *whole year* and they pull this crap? Unbelievable. Even the extras are badly subtitled--there is a seven second delay on all of them.

Due to the subtitle fiasco, I wouldn't recommend this release to people who haven't seen the film before, as they won't even be able to follow the plot as so much dialogue is missing. Pick up the double feature on its own, and for GAMERA 3 stick with the original ADV DVD--the picture on it wasn't great, but it was at least watchable AND had excellent English subtitles.

Image and sound quality is very good on the three movies, especially on the third one. The cardboard slipcase is colorful and attractive, with a very professional design, much better than other Mill Creek releases. The problem of this set are the subtitles on the second disc: the movie "Gamera 3" has lots of missing and out of sync sentences which make the movie much less enjoyable (for example, Kurata Shinya's explanation of the Gamera graveyard is totally lost if you watch the movie that way). And subtitles on extra features get progressively out of sync until there is a delay of seven seconds between characters speaking and subtitles appearing on screen. It's something regrettable which should have been corrected before release and keeps this release from being totally recommended.

I was really looking forward to this set the minute I saw it. The picture quality was awesome and the deleted scenes and behind-the-scene extras were a nice bonus. However, the fact that English subtitles drop 1 in 8 lines of dialogue is inexcusable. They didn't even re-dub the English version, simply reapplying the ADV dub. The only improvements I can find about this version is the picture quality and the box art..... It's a terrible shame because these films deserve so much more than this lack-luster treatment

It had been a really long time since I had seen a Gamera movie. Couldn't even tell you what the title of the last one I saw was.

This collection is awesome. Much better than the older versions. Of course technology has advanced, but I thought the story lines were pretty good and the newer Gamera is much more "viscous" looking.

All-in-all a great buy. What a way for me to introduce Gamera to my children! Loved it, would recommend it to anyone.

Go turtle power!

I love Gamera as much as I like Godzilla! I watched most of his movies from the 1960s, dispite that they were all a little goofy, they really appealed to the kid in all of us! And now we have these three movie for the 90s;
1. GAMERA, GUARDIAN OF THE UNIVERSE
It was great to see the big guy in action again!
What I liked about it;
1. Gamera looked better than he did before in the 60s!
2. Gamera sounded better!
3. The Gyaos looked better and sounded better!
4. The characters all served a good purpose!

What I didn't like;
1. The battles could have been better!
2. The Gyaos had weird/ rolling eyes!

Overall; I liked this movie! My grade: B or three-and-a-half stars!

2. GAMERA: ATTACK OF THE LEGION
A major improvement of the last one!
What I liked;
1. Gamera just looked and sounded better and was an imposing fighter!
2. The visual effects just keep getting better and better!
3. The Legion wer and looked very scary!
4. The battles were well done!
5. The plot was great!

Overall; I liked this movie even more than the first!
My grade; B+ or four stars!

3. GAMERA: REVENGE OF IRIS
The best Gamera movie yet!
What I liked about it;
1. Gamera looked bigger and more imposing than ever before!
2. I liked how all the human characters were tied into the plot!
3. The plot was complex and well written!
4. Iris looked cool!
5. The visual effects were excellent!

Overall; This is the best made Gamera film yet! My grade: A or five stars!

Bottom line; If you are a Gamera fan or just like monster movies, this 3-pack is for you!
My grand grade: A-

If you're reading this, I am probably preaching to the choir. If not, do please know that this mid-90's trilogy is just about the best daikaiju eiga (sp?) ever, with really special effects, solid storytelling & acting, and less of the silliness that detracts from this type of film. We're a looonngg way from the lesser, MST3K-ed Gameras with alien chicks trying to eat little boys' brains here, folks! I titled this Grateful because we finally have the trilogy on Blu, with strong transfers and some (although not many) extras. This is a good given that physical media will be dead in the foreseeable future and the Cloud will never be able to render these films with this detail; if it someday can (or does), let's face it, these films are not likely candidates for that jump. Best of all - way inexpensive! If you *have* seen these movies and are wondering, get 'em. The transfers are dandy, the effects hold up to the scrutiny, and the films really are as good as you remember. If you are one of those who have not seen them and are perusing Amazon or were led here by a link, wondering what all the fuss is - take a chance. The price makes this an extremely low-risk venture, and if you're at all comfortable with GODZILLA, GORGO, WAR OF THE GARGANTUAS, KING KONG, and the real winners of the genre, these belong in the conversation.