77 of 83 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
A Book of Historical Inaccuracies, July 21, 2002
This review is from: Gandhi (Hardcover)
The author has obviously spent a great deal of time and effort in making her illustrations authentic as well as beautiful. Unfortunately, the authenticity of this recount of Mahatma Gandhi's life ends there. The author seems to have failed in spending even a minute in researching the facts surrounding the great Mahatma Gandhi's life. Starting with the very first sentence, the author begins to rewrite the life of Mahatma Gandhi according to her own political or personal agenda, without any regard to the truth surrounding this great soul's life. Had she only taken the time to read the first few pages of Mahatma Gandhi's own, handwritten autobiography (available in numerous languages, including English), she would find most of the statements she has made regarding Gandhi's religious upbringing, personal beliefs and life quests are wholly inaccurate and in most cases, complete fabrications.
Here are only a few examples of the historical inaccuracies that the author has included in this so-called fact-based biography:
Mahatma Gandhi was a Hindu, not a Jain as stated by the author. Furthermore, his entire life philosophy was based on Hindu teachings.
Gandhi fought many existing social injustices of the time, but his primary battle, the battle which earned him the title of "Mahatma" or "Great Soul" was that against the British for India's independence. The author states this battle almost as an aside to that of his fight against caste-based prejudicial practices.
India and Pakistan were the two countries formed at the end of this great Independence Struggle, however, India was not formed as "Hindu India" as the author states. India was created a democracy and remains a democracy to date. In fact, 75% of India's Muslims chose to remain in India rather than relocating to Pakistan during Partition, which, incidentally was created as a Muslim state.
I am dismayed by both the author's and publisher's lack of regard to historical accuracy, especially in a biographical medium that will, in all likelihood, be used as an educational source for children.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
20 of 22 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Searching for a World Hero, October 17, 2001
By A Customer
This review is from: Gandhi (Hardcover)
This beautiful biography causes child and adult to stop and think about the power of our actions. Throughout his life, Gandhi viewed every challenge he faced as an opportunity to serve others. He especially wanted to challenge the evils of prejudice, but only in nonviolent ways. After reading this book as an adult, I found myself longing for a present-day world leader with his spiritual strength. After reading the book to my third graders, I saw how this leader from the past could still influence thinking of today's people. They were very moved by Gandhi's non-violent beliefs and decided to put this quote (from the dust jacket)up on our classroom bulletin board: "If you want to see the brave, look at those who can forgive. If you want to see the heroic, look at those who can love in return for hatred." Demi has succeeded in making Gandhi a timeless world figure for young children--both in her words and illustrations. I thank her for this incredible book; in light of our current world events, I think Gandhi's teachings are very powerful for all of us.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
6 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Fictional "History". This book is not even based on historical events and people., February 3, 2008
This review is from: Gandhi (Hardcover)
The author does not know much about Mahatma Gandhi and his life. Almost everything the author says about the great man's life is inaccurate. In fact, should this bok have been about a North American leader the author would have ended up paying damages for the ridiculously erroneous potrayal of a historical personality. The authors ignorance is almost criminal.
In this world, where cultures are divided and we seem to be constantly in war, it is important to educate children with accurate information. This books takes up a world personality who was born and lived in a different country, and our little children form impressions about these cultures from these windows to those cultures. Calling India a "Hindu" India is an insult to India. It is the largest democracy in the world and one of the very few secular countries. The country DOES NOT have a religious identity. In fact it has the second largest muslim population in the world and to my knowledge, has more christians living there than in the United States of America.
Please do not waste your money on this book
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No