From Publishers Weekly
Lamm (The Prog Frince: A Mixed-Up Tale) opens this lyrical, somewhat sentimental story with a note explaining the title: in Argentina, to make a gauchada means "to do something kind, something with love, without expecting anything in return." Sitting in a field amidst cows, a gaucho carves a piece of bone into a crescent-shaped moon, which he then frames with silver and makes into a necklace. Next, the ideas grow a bit abstract and the narrative becomes labyrinthine: "Perhaps after the rains have again greened the pampas, perhaps after the cows stampede through the quebradas, perhaps after he has danced a thousand zambas, sometime after that the gaucho who chose the bone and smoothed the silver and placed the stone will know." What he will know is "where the necklace will go." After the cowboy places the pendant around the neck of his grandmother, the necklace "lives a thousand lives," as it is passed from one individual to another. After the heirloom "crosses the ocean" on a liner, worn by a woman writer, the narrative swerves from its melancholy, introspective tone to address readers directly (the woman writer will give the gift of the necklace "perhaps to you"). If the prose is cryptic, the artwork smoothly blends folkloric elements with sweeping landscapes. Infused with light often that of the moon itself Negrin's (The Secret Footprints) stylized, ethereal paintings effectively tweak traditional perspective and proportion. Ages 4-8.
Copyright 2002 Cahners Business Information, Inc.
From School Library Journal
Grade 2-5-Lamm's gentle story follows the path of a gauchada, or selfless gift-in this case, a handmade necklace in the shape of a moon. A gaucho, or Argentine cowboy, carves it from a piece of bone and hangs it from a silver chain. He gives it to an old woman, who gives it to a younger woman, who gives it to a little girl, and so on. The gauchada makes its way around the world, and finally the story ends when its most recent recipient recalls the cowboy back in Argentina who carved it. Negrin skillfully manipulates proportion and scale to good effect; his animals and people are all endowed with abundant limbs and torsos offset by delicate facial features. Text and illustrations work together nicely in this quiet story about sharing special presents. However, it's all a bit arcane, and it's unlikely that most children will grasp the difference between a selfless gift and any gift. A special book without much child appeal.
Catherine Threadgill, Charleston County Public Library, SC Copyright 2002 Reed Business Information, Inc.