From School Library Journal
Grade 10 Up?Representing many time periods, nationalities, and occupations, these 275 biographical sketches offer a wide-ranging look at gay and lesbian notables. The spectrum makes this book unique, although it may startle some readers to find artists, scientists, politicians, sports figures, literary icons, female impersonators, and others under the same cover. Highly readable, alphabetically arranged entries vary in length from a few paragraphs to several pages. Most articles include black-and-white photographs or sketches and a list of references. The text does not dwell on sexuality, though available facts that are important to understanding the individual or their work are included. Three useful indexes provide access by nationality, occupation, and subject area. When a great deal of information about an individual (Eleanor Roosevelt or Emily Dickinson) is available from other sources, the need for this volume may be questionable. Some critics may point out that there is little real documentation to place such people in these pages. However, much of the material found here is not available in other reliable sources. This is especially true of contemporary writers, scholars, and activists. Also, the book is easy to use and, in places, almost as fascinating as an armchair read. A unique resource.?Sue A. Norkeliunas, Arlington Senior High School, LaGrangeville, NY
Copyright 1998 Reed Business Information, Inc.
From Library Journal
Endorsed by the American Library Association's Gay, Lesbian, and Bisexual Task Force and compiled under the guidance of an advisory board of librarians and writers, this single-volume biographical dictionary brings together entries on 275 notable people from a full range of professions and historical epochs. The nationality index shows a strong bent toward U.S. and British citizens, and the occupation and general subject indexes demonstrate a propensity for literary figures. Such imbalances, however, are inevitable given the breadth of the subject and defensible given the presumptive audience. The real problem lies in the entries, contributed largely by nonspecialist freelance writers. Ranging from a single column to over two pages, each entry opens with the entrant's name, years of birth and (when appropriate) death, and occupation, followed by a narrative essay, current address (again, when appropriate), and citations to the books and/or magazine articles used in compiling the essay. The essays themselves vary in writing quality, though most catch the important events and, appropriately, emphasize the "queerer" aspects of the entrant's lives. But the decision not to include lists of works for writers, filmmakers, and composers is inexplicable. Just as baffling are the references, which overlook important biographies, cite titles incorrectly, and frequently include trivial articles from popular magazines. This could have filled a need, providing honest accounts of a number of figures whose "straightened out" lives are included in more general biographical works. A lack of competition, however, is no excuse for incomplete research. Most libraries can make do with The Gay and Lesbian Literary Heritage (LJ 6/1/95), a masterly work, though narrower in scope. Recommended only for large gay and lesbian studies collections.?Eric Bryant, "Library Journal"
Copyright 1997 Reed Business Information, Inc.