From Publishers Weekly
Tom Flubacher Waddell, New Jersey-born decathlete in the 1968 Olympics in Mexico City and founder of the Gay Games, died of AIDS in San Francisco in 1987 at the age of 49, several months after Schaap had started work on this biography. Toward the end of it, by way of explaining why he took on the project, Schaap, sportswriter and author of 29 books, writes that he has always looked for stories that transcend sport, that provoke laughter or tears, surprise or anger. And Waddell's story, the life of a world-class athlete, a doctor specializing in infectious diseases, a gay activist and, with his lesbian partner, a father, is probably suitably provocative. But Schaap seems to have been singularly unprovoked during the nine years he worked on this book, and he leaves the reader squinting between the lines to find out what made Waddell extraordinary. We are given only disorganized scraps of evidence. Waddell's later history is told in his own words, in the form of letters, which he began composing hours after her conception, to his daughter Jessica, who was four years old at the time of his death; the earlier history is filled in by Schaap. But most of the best writing is found at the end of the book, in quotes from interviewees and excerpts from letters written by Waddell's admirers. The narrative as a whole suffers from an apparent lack of editing and from ineffective, haphazard contextualizing. There is much allusiveness, an abundance of non sequiturs and precious little portraiture. Photos.
Copyright 1996 Reed Business Information, Inc.
From Library Journal
Waddell wanted to do everything: he was a college athlete, a member of the 1968 U.S. Olympic team, a military and civilian doctor, and founder of the Gay Games. So when Sara Lewinstein, a prominent San Francisco lesbian activist, asked him to father her child, he enthusiastically agreed. This book is composed of excerpts from Waddell's journal?which he began for daughter Jessica in 1983 and kept until shortly before he died of complications from AIDS in 1987?mixed with a more straightforward biography by TV sports commentator Schaap. Schaap adequately chronicles Waddell's life from his 1937 birth into a working-class New Jersey family, through his struggles with his homosexuality, to his ultimately unsuccessful battle to use the name "Gay Olympics" for the quadrennial games he founded. Along the way, Schaap makes clear his subject's complicated relationships with women and men, his perfectionism, and his idealism. Though the (auto)biography format is not entirely successful, the result is nevertheless an important testament to one of the queer communities' most inspiring role models.?Jim Van Buskirk, San Francisco P.L.
Copyright 1996 Reed Business Information, Inc.