42 of 42 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
A Strange Mix, November 9, 2005
Genghis Khan by John Man is a strange mix of history and travelogue that doesn't seem to hang well together. Man has attempted to meld his personal experiences travelling Mongolia to visit the major Genghis-related sites with a history of Genghis Khan. As a result, you will find out not only about that 13-th century builder of the Mongol nation and empire but also about Man's trevails attempting to find Burkhan Khaldun, Mongolia's sacred mountain. If you like to see some of the author's personality injected into a story about someone else, this may enhance the book for you. If you find such things unprofessional or uninteresting, this is not the history of Genghis Khan that you want to read.
Genghis Khan the book is clearly written as a popular history. There are few footnotes and little in the way of new ground is broken when it comes to research on Genghis. Instead, Man appears to rely on the established (albeit conflicting) sources that have been used by other scholars. Significantly, Man goes to great lengths to point out and discuss the major debates when it comes to Genghis Khan's life, a major positive point for this book. He also mines previously uncovered primary sources such as The Secret History for all that they are worth.
The book really falls into three sections. The first deals with many of the legends that surround Genghis Khan and his early youth. Due to the lack of sources on Genghis this section reads almost more like mythology than history. The beginning is also marked by a stretch of Man discussing his travels in Mongolia to sites where Genghis may have been born.
After about 50 pages the hazy mythology of Genghis gives way to more detailed and authoritative accounts of the major events of Genghis' rise to power and his conquest of China and Eurasia. This account forms the second section of the book and lasts for about 200 pages. Man's account deals mostly with political events and does not delve into much detail regarding Genghis' personal life, likely because such information simply does not exist. However, Man paints a portrait of Genghis as ruler, including his willingness to learn from the technology and education of his enemies both to increase the Mongols' military might and to improve administration in the newly-won and ravaged territories.
The final section of the book reverts back to mythology and speculation and deals with Genghis' death and burial. Since the location of Genghis' grave remains unknown, it is an attractive target for research, and Man is clearly fascinated by the issue. Like the first section, this section contains long passages regarding Man's search for possible grave locations, including details about what he ate and who his guides were.
While I personally do not care for the way that Man has interjected himself, the book remains extremely readable and accessable to the non-expert on Mongolia. While Man makes the point that Genghis was not the mindless barbarian that so many histories portray, he also does not shy away from discussing the scale of the descruction wroght by the Mongols. Because of the passage of time and the lack of credible primary sources, it is impossible to tell how many people perished under Mongol swords, but Man does an admirable job of trying to parse the approximate numbers. He doesn't flinch from discussing the negatives of the Mongols and deserves credit for not turning this project into a hagiography.
The bottom line is that this is not a book for experts but is not a bad jumping-off point for someone with a casual interest in Genghis Khan. I suspect that this book is particularly useful and interesting for people who may actually be travelling to Mongolia on business or a lark and want to get oriented. I just think that the melding of the author's personal experiences with the history of Genghis the man detracts from the overall quality of what is otherwise a good survey of one of the most important figures of the last 2,000 years.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
9 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Chinggis Khan...??? Temujin...?? Genghis Khan...sound familiar?..read on..., December 14, 2005
The book gives a general idea of the "man", his background, his conquests and the mystery that eludes and shrouds him. The Great Khan is truly mysterious...and with limited historical records, I am greatful that the author has sacrificed time and effort to personally experience, the Mongolian experience, in order to get in touch with the atmosphere and conditons that Genghis may have experienced. These personal accounts sometimes got in my way while reading, I just wanted the author to get on with it... yet at times these personal accounts were justifiable as they helped in clarifying certain points.
Overall, I'd say the book was ok... its in my personal book collection... my quest for another book on the Great Khan will not end here...
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
History's Most Lovable Bloodthirsty Tyrant, April 15, 2006
Mainstream historians may object to some of the claims in this book, but John Man has created quite a readable mix of travelogue and history. This is more a work of interpretation, rather than direct research, as Man has combined his own past learning about Genghis Khan and the Mongols with his modern-day travels to Mongolia in search of surviving relics. So do not expect newly detailed research breakthroughs, because this is one of those "living history" books. One particular problem is that Man uses a lot of conjecture and opinionating when tackling gaps or contradictions in the historical record. But in the end, we do get a very good summary of all the present knowledge on Genghis and his descendants, and Man engagingly discusses this very intriguing and complex historical personage. This especially applies to how Genghis was surely a genius in military strategy and administration, and was a remarkable leader of men, while also being responsible for the destruction of dozens of classic cities and the slaughter of probably a few million people. Man also discusses the sheer hugeness of the Mongols' empire-building practices, why these once-anarchic nomads decided to destroy every settled civilization in the known world then return to their simple pastoral lives, and how Genghis has been deified as both a god and a devil by multiple societies ever since. Add to this Man's exploration of the modern landscape and the Mongols' ongoing influence, and this conjectural but still very readable book really shows what made Genghis and his boys tick. [~doomsdayer520~]
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No