Most Helpful Customer Reviews
19 of 23 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Questionable consolation for parents of AS kids, don't expect more, March 30, 2008
This review is from: Genius Genes: How Asperger Talents Changed the World (Paperback)
I'm a father of a kid with Asperger Syndrome, and I'm also a Ph.D. in psychology and neuroscience. When I saw the title, I was attracted by the word "HOW", i.e. what are the possible special psychological traits of AS, and how these traits link with creativity, discoveries and achievements - I want the updated research findings. And further more, I also hoped to get suggestions about how to parent a kid with AS, who may possess some "genius genes" but meanwhile clearly have multiple difficulties. Without passing these hurdles, even the basic success will be questionable to these AS kids. I'm disappointed when I got this book because it almost exclusively talks about second-hand biographies or even legends of some great people in history who "may" have Asperger Syndrome. Although the authors sound very confident to make their "diagnosis" of AS on these great figures (such as Newton, Einstein, Thomas Jefferson), I personally don't think it is accurate (such as in Newton's case). Anyway, this is not what I care, and I don't need the consolation that since many great people have AS, I should feel better (I don't feel bad for my son). On the other hand, although the first author is an expert of AS, I'm surprise that this book lack two important things: 1. An analysis AS itself - at least these parts relevant to the topic, such as what factors are important for the future success (I don't mean to be a Newton) of an AS kid. 2. An analysis of Today's successful figures with AS. AS is not a rare disorder, there must be many highly achieved "geniuses" with AS nowadays in this world. Who are they, where are they, what are their psychological traits, what are their life stories, what make them successful (nature or nurture)...? I feel that the authors are not able to answer these important questions, but instead they pick a shortcut to write a book with fancy title.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
8 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Interesting Read, March 26, 2008
This review is from: Genius Genes: How Asperger Talents Changed the World (Paperback)
Genius Genes is an interesting review of a number of intellectuals, generals and politicians that may have met the criteria of Aspergers Syndrome or Aspergers Disorder. The brief biographies are concise and informative using some of the best biographies written about these individuals and present the evidence that the authors want to use to prove their position on the individual's diagnosis. Their thesis that Asperger's is one way for the emergence of creative and gifted thinking is proven if you accept that the highlighted individuals were Aspergers. This book helps supply information regarding my interest in people who are creative, and those who are genius or near genius. It helps explain some of their quirks and what makes them interesting, and most of us have met someone that meets this definition. Despite loving the book, I found the book repetitive at times. I also had some difficulty with the authors' overly frequent comparison of the individuals highlighted with philosophier Ludwig Wittgenstein. I found these frequent comparsions very distracting, and I felt if he was such a perfect case of Aspergers that a chapter should have been added and devoted to him. So distracting were these comparsions for me that I nearly rated the book as a 4 verse the 5 I gave it. This book could be used as the basis for the belief that being 'normal' is not 'holy grail' for humanity. What is 'normal' anyway? Who wants to be mundane/normal anyway -- especially considering some of the crack pots who are trying to define what 'normal' is -- see the section on behaviorist J. B. Watson and the implications of his social engineering views to see my point?
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Daring,Controversial,Brilliant Book, October 15, 2008
This review is from: Genius Genes: How Asperger Talents Changed the World (Paperback)
It takes a very original thinker to see a relationship between autistic children and Newton.Aspergers Syndrome,the missink link between Autism and Genius has mysteriosly been absent from the professional literature in the US untill recently.THe field was dominated for too long by Bruno Bettelheim and supporters,who denied a genetic basis and gave us instead Freudian fairy tales.The next book should seek to explain why the public is only now learning science that was first published in Germany in 1940. THis is a fascinating groundbreaking book.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|