3 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
The Hobo Philosopher, June 2, 2010
Gentleman Spy
By Peter Grose
Book Review
By Richard E. Noble
Opinions on Allen Dulles range from prominent diplomat, CIA mastermind and raconteur to a traitorous, conniving scoundrel, who sold out his country for personal gain. His Brother Foster is held in exactly the same regard.
This book I would not rank as the definitive biography of Allen Dulles. A definitive biography, it would be my guess, has not yet been written - and may never be written. This man and this family have more skeletons in its closet than one book could possibly contain - even a 641 page tome as this one.
To go even further, I would not define the main purpose of this book to be a biography of Allen Dulles. This is a history book dealing with the establishment of the CIA and its evolution over the years.
The CIA begins as a rather simple and primitive wartime intelligence gathering agency. It starts out in the late 40's and evolves into a giant government secret organization with unlimited, untraceable funds following the pattern of the Russian KGB or the Nazi SS.
It actually incorporates into it nefarious folds ex-members of the German SS and other Nazi organizations - "good Germans" according to Mr. Allen Dulles' conscience and a book he published.
It becomes involved with torture, killing, espionage, assassination, fomenting revolution, toppling foreign governments, and creating havoc and discord around the world on behalf of the American government for purposes often difficult to determine. This is not accusation; it is fact. You can read about it almost anywhere and in hundreds of books.
As head of the CIA and one of its initial founders Allen Dulles is everywhere and involved in things yet to be disclosed. But once again, I will repeat, this book is less about Mr. Allen Dulles as it is about the CIA and its evolution and its intrigues around the world.
If you are into studying this subject you will find this book to be more of an encyclopedia of well known and well documented facts.
Politically speaking I would say this book is middle of the road if not leaning somewhat to the right.
Allen Dulles' position with regards to his clients at Sullivan and Cromwell is explained clearly. Allen is a defender of moneyed interests. It matters little if his clients have their money invested in Nazi German munitions plants, or in smuggling war supplies into Nazi occupied territory. It is all American money and American money anywhere is worth defending and securing. Profit is profit - all wars aside. For most of us nearer to the bottom of the human food chain this is hardly a tenable position.
Allen, it becomes clear, is first a smart lawyer defending the interests of his moneyed clients and second, a government employee or whatever else might come along to advance his position and personal fortune.
He is a philanderer, and if you can believe this author, more concerned with the morality and ethics of his decision making, at least, than his brother Foster. His wife Clover seems to have been much more than he deserved.
The book does not go into details of investigations of Sullivan and Cromwell or any other of the Dulles financial investments and activity - shenanigans may be a better word. The author dismisses the bulk of these controversies as political in nature and skips on past.
The book contains lots of valid, documented information, very few opinions and avoids most anything controversial. Oh it states what happened or what was said but no controversial details. You will find all the prominent misfits from the annals of "spy" fame - Kolbe, Angleton, Donovan, Philby, Oswald, E. Howard Hunt and the rest. But I found nothing I didn't already know.
This book is a good mainstream overview of the CIA, the spy Game and Allen Dulles. But if you are looking for a scathing, no holds barred, in depth expose of the life, times, and shadowy involvements of Mr. Dulles and friends, this is not your book. This is a good, solid, conventional history book. If you want more "meat" I guess that you will have to wait for the unauthorized biography by Kitty Kelley - though, you will get more "fluff" than meat there, no doubt.
Richard Edward Noble - The Hobo Philosopher - Author of:
"Mein Kamp - An Analysis of Book One"
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No