70 of 71 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
engaging fiction!, January 12, 2006
First of all, for the cricket-ignorant, up until WW II in
English first-class cricket, the people who played the game
were classified as "gentlemen"--those who played the game
without pay--and "players"--the paid professionals. In the
box-score, a gentleman would appear as Mr Smith, and a
professional would appear as Jones. Separate dessing-rooms
were provided for the two groups. There was an annual match
Gentlemen vs Players. It was very rare that a team captain
would be a player: there was a significant gulf between the
leisure class and the working class.
The novel is about the child of the working-class man who did
the janitorial chores at St Oswald's School, an expensive
day school for sons of privilege. The child, now grown up,
forges documents to join the school as a new faculty member,
with the intention of destroying the institution from within.
So small unpleasant things begin to happen--and things get
worse with thefts and scandals. It's a game--but only the
player knows it--the gentlemen (which includes female faculty)
are puzzled and disconcerted. The other central figure is Roy
Straitley, classics master, now in his 34th year at St Oswald's.
Straitley is Old School, computer-ignorant, but shrewd enough
to finally realize that there is a game going on. The gentlemen
are accustomed to interacting with gentlemen (faculty and
students) at the school--they are at a great disadvantage
against a working-class person who doesn't play by the rules.
The sense of dichotomy is wonderfully drawn here--those of
privilege, and those who are not. There are fine lines of
snobbery. Gentlemen & Players has similar layers--depths and
nuances. An excellent read!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
43 of 43 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Deadly Game of Chess, February 5, 2007
This clever novel has just been nominated for the Edgar Allan Poe award by the Mystery Writers of America, and it's easy to see why. St. Oswald's, an exclusive British boy's school, is the scene of a deadly contest between a dedicated old "Mr. Chips"-type teacher and a mysterious newcomer to the faculty. Each opponent tells the story in alternating chapters, and it soon becomes clear that the evil interloper has a beef with the place dating back to childhood. This new teacher is secretly waging an insidious campaign of terror against St. Oswald's, the clear intent being to bring the famous school down and close its doors forever. And only our hero--a fussy, eccentric, out-of-shape old-timer--can stop the tragedy, if he can find his anonymous adversary in time....
Harris (CHOCOLAT, FIVE QUARTERS OF THE ORANGE) hits the ground running with her first suspense novel, and it's as funny as it is bizarre, a truly black comedy. A former teacher in a Brit boys' school, Harris knows the institutions and their people very well. She has a marvelous way of describing everything, and her names for the characters are particularly Dickensian. The heroic teacher is named Straitley, the villain is named Snyde, and other teachers and students are appropriately named Meek, Strange, Knight, Bishop, Devine, Fallow, Brasenose, Shakeshafte, etc. She makes you feel that you're actually there, in the school, witnessing the "game." Highly recommended.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
23 of 24 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Two competing narrators and a very well-concealed twist, January 24, 2007
I'm reviewing the P.S. version of 'Gentlemen and Players' because it contains an insightful five-page 'On My Mind' piece by the Joanne Harris. Harris discusses her history as a teacher - 12 years teaching at a Boys' Grammar School in the UK. As the intro to that piece states, her teaching experience was "put to good use in the deeply atmospheric 'Gentlemen and Players.'"
Indeed.
I also have to make mention of the compelling cover of the P.S. release, design courtesy of Robin Bilardello. It makes this work fairly leap off the shelves and into your hands. It's what encouraged me to flip through the book in the store.
The book itself holds up well. The style taken on here by Ms. Harris - two competing narrators and a very well-concealed twist - is not one taken easily by an unskilled writer. She pulls it off very well. Harris is best known as the author of 'Chocolat' (basis of the movie of the same name). Reviews elsewhere call that her best work, while others put votes in for 'Five Quarters of the Orange.' 'Gentlemen and Players' was my introduction to her work. I came out very impressed and definitely a new fan of her work.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No