15 of 16 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Flawed biography, April 6, 2005
Among the good-to-great Presidents of the United States, there can be a lot of debate as to who is second-best, but number one on the list - both chronologically and in importance - is George Washington. Yes, he had his problems, including slave ownership and a spotty military success rate, but these are outweighed by his contributions.
In the early United States, there were few unifying figures. Most of the founders were associated with a certain region or political philosophy. Other than the elderly Benjamin Franklin, only Washington received the universal respect that was necessary to keep the fragile nation together. Another figure - John Adams, Thomas Jefferson, Alexander Hamilton or someone else - would not have had the necessary following to keep the United States truly united. Aware of his role in history, Washington was a careful executive; he correctly recognized that his every action would set precedents.
Willard Sterne Randall's biography of Washington is a flawed piece of work. On the one hand, he has created a pleasantly readable book. On the other hand, his focus is almost exclusively on Washington's early years. The Revolution doesn't really begin until halfway into the book and the Presidency is covered in scarcely more than fifty pages. It seems almost as if Randall got bored writing after a certain point and started getting sketchier in the details.
Randall also needed a better editor or fact-checker. Little flaws can be found: in one place, he wrongly describes Hamilton as being the son of a British admiral; a few pages later, Hamilton is correctly described as the son of a Scottish merchant.
In the end, this is a passable biography, a weak three-star effort. Those (including myself) seeking a definitive biography of Washington, will need to look elsewhere. This book is not bad, but it doesn't rate that high.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
12 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A very good overview of Washington's life and times, November 3, 1999
I read this book in hopes of learning more about the nation's first president. I have always found Washington to be a fascinating person but I never did know very many details about his personal life. In school we learn about the legend who overcame great odds and could do no wrong when leading this nation into freedom and independence. Willard Randall focuses on George Washington the man by providing you with an interesting insight into Washington's personal relationships, his shortcomings and his ambitions. The book also focuses on his early career as a soldier in the French and Indian War and as a member of General Braddock's ill-fated expedition. It does an excellent job of describing the environment and events which led Washington to make the decision to lead the Continental army against the British knowing that he would lose everything if he was not successful. There are probably other books on George Washington that are more detailed and thorough but if you want a general overview that is interesting and easy to read then this is the book that I highly recommend.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
12 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Excellent book on Washington the soldier, April 14, 2002
Perhaps the title is misleading. This book does not cover in detail the life of George Washington. His presidency is glossed over. Those looking to read in depth about the days of Wahsington's presidency should probably look elsewhere. It's focus is mainly on the young Washington who was driven to be a British military officer and became the Patriot General determined to drive the British out of America. I felt Randall put a human touch on Washington, at times describing his emotions at key moments in his life, avoiding the "father of our country" caricature that our school history text books tend to show us. Several pages are devoted to his relationship with the woman that was probably the love of his life and his struggles with perhaps his greatest enemy, Benedict Arnold. Attention is given early in the book on Washington, the boy, and what shaped him to grow into the man he became. I disagree with the mediocre to negative reviews given to this book. I feel that it puts a human face on one of the greatest men this country has produced and focuses on, what to me, is the most interesting period of Washington's life. This book is an interesting, easy read. Randall is not a Pulitzer Prize winning author for nothing.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No