3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A very good overview of the 1st ships of the new German Navy, March 2, 2007
This review is from: German Light Cruisers of World War II: Emden, Konigsberg, Karlsruhe, Koln, Leipzig, Nurnberg (Hardcover)
Gerhard Koop does an excellent job writing up the design, construction, and operational life of the German light cruisers of WWII.
These ships were all limited by restructions by the treaty that ended The Great War. So, unlike the later "Panzerschiffe" which pretty much openly cheated on the treaty, the German followed the treaty to the letter on these light cruisers. The end result was the Germans got some very expensive coastal cruisers, they were not better that "light cruiser monitors".
Everything on the later ships will strike the typical reader as a little off. There is a picture of an Omaha Class US cruiser sailing with a Kohn class cruiser, both had about the same fire power but the US ship was a far better sea ship even though it had rivet construction that could stand little battle damage, as when the USS Marblehead nearly sank when a 550 pound bomb exploded close to the ship and popped all the rivets in her stern.
Gerhard Koop's book is good. Yes, I gave it only four stars. He has rather crude line drawings in the book and they are near useless to get any informantion from. I was hoping that this book would be like the excellent series of books from Dr. Norman Friedman. This is not the case. However, there are many excellent picures and very good write ups on the operational history of these ships.
However, this reviewer is generally happy with the book. It gives a complete write up on all the light cruisers in WWII, their design histories, operational usage, and their ultimate fates.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No