Customer Reviews

A Gershwin Night

5 star:		(6)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

In this special concert, such popular Gershwin works as 'An American in Paris', 'Rhapsody in Blue' and 'Concerto in F'
were performed by Berlin philharmonic (conductor: Seiji Ozawa) and Marcus Roberts Trio led by Marcus Roberts, one of the most renowned jazz pianists.

Except the first one, the other two were arranged by Marcus Roberts especially for the solo piano parts, and the rendition is actually far from the Gershwin's original. They sound a lot more jazzy than classical. Some might say "This is not what I expected!" because they are different that we have heard. I admit that three too long solo parts by the trio ruined the essence of the 'Rhapsody in Blue'. To me, however, the concert was still very enjoyable and entertainig maybe because I like jazz too. Marcus' piano was so great and sweet to listened to. (He's blind, by the way.) The trio also played "I got Rhythm" in their style.

I think this concert is a special treat from both the world's finest orchestra Berlin Phil and the trio. This kind of concert is not usual at all. It is like "once-in-a-life-time concert". It was also fun to watch the Japanese conductor Seiji Ozawa, whose facial expressions were sometimes humorous and funny. I also liked the atmosphere of the open-air theater of the Berlin Waldbuhne. Camera work is not perfect but great. In extra feature "They Got Rhythm", Marcus Roberts Trio is introduced in details. Sound formats include DD 5.1, DTS 5.1, PCM stereo. Sound/video quality is excellent.

I recommend to any music lovers except those who want a pure classical performance.

I loved everything about this DVD and I think Gershwin would have too. His love for and knowledge of both jazz and classical music is apparent in all of his music. So.. as I said, I loved everything about this DVD... the orchestra is phenomenal, Seiji Ozawa is superb, and the Marcus Roberts Trio...well what can I say? They infuse the music with rhythmic power and sheer joy. I've seen this group on stage and their sound is so cohesive and powerful that it's evident that these guys (Marcus Roberts, Jason Marsalis, Roland Guerin) love to play together. Sometimes a recording disappoints after hearing a group like this live, but not here. If you love jazz and/or classical music, I rush right out to buy this DVD.

I purchased this dvd as a gift for a family member who had been talking about this performance he saw for over 1 yr. Needless to say he was extremely happy when I gave him the dvd. I was extremely happy that I was able to find it at Amazon.com Many Thanks

The first time I saw the performance was on the Arts channel. I like Seiji Ozawa's conducting very much and he looked so cute in the Tuxedo. I was suspecting the pianist is a blind man when I first watched the performance. I bought the DVD just to see how Ozawa conducting the jazz music rather than classic music. I watched Ozawa's conducting Vienna New Years concert in 2002 right before this one. After such classic performance I wanted something more relax. When I saw Ozawa leading the pianist out, I realized this is probably much difficult than what seemed to be on the DVD. At first I was not sure if the pianist is good at what he is doing. This may not be what Gershwin original intended way to express the music, but I like it for the sake of giving the less advantage person a chance to express his way to interpret the music. I do not know how Seiji Ozawa and the whole Orchestra is able to work with a blind pianist who is not able to see the conductor. A lot of effort must be put in to make it possible. However, my mother had no problem to recognize the music when she heard them at all. I enjoyed the American in Paris. I am more impressed that the pianist is able to remember the music and plays like a normal pianist. I have great respect to everyone who is involved in making this DVD possible for the audience.

I recommend this DVD for everyone. The best fusion of Classical music with Jazz. Congratulations to Seiji Ozawa, Marcus Robert Trio and the Berlin Philharmoniker musicians. Amazon international service was perfect! I receive the DVD intact at Rio de Janeiro.

I purchased this immediately after seeing a clip of the Marcus Roberts Trio from this concert on Art TV. The Berlin Philharmonic and Seiji Ozawa are superb, and my family and I loved the Marcus Roberts trio and their take on parts of Blue Rhapsody. Although some may not appreciate modern jazz in this instance, I think it added beautifully to a already iconic masterpiece. I have heard Blue Rhapsody many times and love it, and I thought this version was creative and fitting for a Gerwshin concert. The rest of the pieces round out an amazing performance. This is a great concert and dvd to add to any collection. I recommend this to anyone to that loves music. Outstanding!

Great for Gershwin and jazz fans. Some unique arrangements make this an out of the ordinary performance. Cool Groovy, the whole family loved it

I did not know that Marcus Roberts would completely destroy Rhapsody in Blue and other Gershwin musics.

For me this DVD was a complete deception! I really do NOT recommend it for those who buy a DVD hoping to listen to Gershwin.