Customer Reviews

Gershwin's Rhapsody in Blue

5 star:		(4)
4 star:		(2)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(1)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

Jewish immigrants from Eastern Europe arrived in the United States as learners of American culture and within a generation became its creators. In print, on stage and screen, on radio and in the world of music, their children created now iconic works which consciously or unconsciously melded their Jewish roots and American experiences. A prime example is George Gershwin's Rhapsody in Blue, a work that contains elements of Jewish, ragtime and blues music. The concerto is a living example of how a "melting pot society" led to the development of a uniquely American art form.

Through invented dialogue, the author reconstructs Gershwin's thought processes as he begins to envision the music and then creates the work. The only mention of Gershwin's Jewish heritage are references to klezmer music - e.g. "the klezmer band at Ira's bar mitzvah" - but the term is not defined. The terms "ragtime" or "blues" are also not explained. In life, Gershwin was very much influenced not only by the Jewish music of his youth but also by his exposure to African American music.

The book offers a very well written and illustrated glimpse into the creative process of a musical genius and could serve to open further discussion with young readers on the contributions of Jews to American music.

A CD of Rhapsody in Blue (from an original piano roll played by Gershwin himself) accompanies the book. For ages 8-10. Reviewed by Norman H. Finkelstein

A fictionalized account of the creation of George Gershwin's "Rhapsody in Blue" details how the composer was pressured to create a new concerto in just a few weeks, how he was inspired by the rhythm of a train ride, the klezmer band at his brother's Bar Mitzvah, the harmonies of nightclub dance music, ragtime, and the blues, and the enthusiastic reception the piece received at it's first performance. Kitchel's illustrations authentically depict the spirit of the roaring twenties, an author's note gives readers additional information, and the included CD recording provides added value.

This is a great book. It comes with a CD which is wonderful. I am very pleased to have it. I teach elementary music and it is great for my library in my classroom.

This is another evocative and personal book by Ms. Celenza, who has a gift for building a story that appeals to young readers.

This book definitely *does* come with a CD - it is inside the back cover. Perhaps the other reviewer who didn't get a CD was expecting a separate CD case? Regardless, it's a nice combination.

This was a wonderful book. My girls (6 & 8)have played the included CD over and over again. A favorite part is when Gershwin waves his hands in the air and say, "I can't do it!" A great resource to introduce music to kids.

Very nicely done...excellent for classroom use to teach the history and

circumstances surrounding the composition of the tune. I would use it in

conjunction with a unit on Tin Pan Alley or Gershwin, or music of the times. Great gift for aspiring pianists!

I bought the book to frame one of the pages--the illustrations are really a work of art. Beautiful illustrations, but somewhat dull (true) story. Very interesting for those who are looking for an accurate story about Gershwin.

The product description, at the time I ordered it, said it came with the CD. When the book arrived, the mailing label which came directly from McKenzie Books,said the CD was included. The CD was not included. Customer service was rude, would not give me contact information for a supervisor, but I am able to return the book. I will believe I get a refund when see it.

This is a wonderful book but I was sad to discover after receiving not only my first order without a CD, but my second REPLACEMENT order as well, that Amazon does not include your CD recording with your purchase as described. I would recommend searching elsewhere for this book.