101 of 112 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
a review, hopefully helpful to all, October 28, 2004
This review is from: Get Your War On II (Paperback)
You know what I've noticed? At the bottom of every review on Amazon, it asks "Was this review helpful to you?" and lets you click on yes or no. Yet perusual of books on any controversial subject - especially politics - leads me to suspect that people often vote yes/no on "do I agree with the politics of the reviewer?"
I'll try to review GYWO2 in a way that at least will be helpful for anyone, whether you saw "Farrenheit 9/11" or whether you never trust anyone not on Fox News.
This book collects a comic strip, which is entirely 3-panel strips using clip art. Presumably Rees wanted to do a comic but can't draw. The illustrations all show office workers talking, with a few variations, enough to suggest Rees is trying (and partly succeeding) to use the comics medium fully. It also suggests an "everyman perspective" for the material. All of the strips are on politics, almost always foreign policy - as the title suggests, the war on terror is the main focus. Here's a typical one-liner from this collection:
"Will future historians describe Bush's foreign policy as the Grand Theft Auto school of diplomacy?"
If you found that amusing, this looks like the book for you. If you're a conservative who found that to be a pile of crap, then definitely avoid this book, because it is pretty much all scathing criticism of the Bush administration.
A couple other factors that might influence your purchasing decision: this is also not a book for those who feel uncomfortable/offended by lots of swearing. Also of note, the author's royalties go to a charity that clears landmines from Afghanistan and other areas (though you could just contribute to them directly if you like).
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
33 of 34 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A merciless mockery of post-9/11 America, January 25, 2006
This review is from: Get Your War On II (Paperback)
After completing a tour of duty in Afghanistan, I read David Rees' "Get Your War On" and was not overly impressed; I wrote a decidedly unenthusiastic review of the book. I read that book's follow-up, "Get Your War On II" about two years later, after completing a tour in Iraq. Either Rees' writing has gotten sharper, or I just became more receptive to his work, because I think that GYWO2 is brilliant. This book of cartoons maintains the general format and style of its predecessor, and also follows up on the original's subject matter. The cartoons generally depict a bunch of anonymous white-collar office drones who discuss the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, as well as other topics from early 21st-century headlines.
Rees has crafted a richly ironic volume of political satire that is full of profanity and scathing dialogue. Nobody is safe--along the way his nameless characters mock George Bush, Tony Blair, Halliburton, Fox News, Fidel Castro, Condoleezza Rice, Joe Lieberman, _The New York Times_, Ahmad Chalabi, Tom Daschle, North Korea, Pat Robertson, Ted Koppel, and many other entities. Rees covers many topics: gang rape, abortion, genocide, anthrax mailings, the search for WMDs in Iraq, political saber-rattling over steroid abuse, the 9/11 commission, the Abu Ghraib prisoner abuse scandal, proposed designs for the new World Trade Center, and more. Adding to the pungent flavor of the book are the characters' many absurd pop culture references--Paris Hilton, 2 Live Crew, _Tiger Beat_, _The Family Circus_, etc. It's all made even funnier by the generally bland appearances of Rees' characters.
Rees is at his best when he is deconstructing and reshaping the jargon and catchphrases of the post-9/11 U.S.: "Axis of Evil," "Coalition of the Willing," "Freedom Fries," and many more. He offers a lacerating meditation on the use of language as a propaganda tool. His characters exchange some harsh and thought-provoking comments on language--I love it when one drone chides another, "Parsed much?" Although most of the characters are his typical anonymous office workers, this book also features "Uzbekikitty," an absurd yet tragic metaphor for U.S. coalition building in the War on Terror. At times Rees also plays with and mocks his own format. Among his routines in the book is a series of biting knock-knock jokes.
Despite the humor of the book, I consider it a serious interrogation of the language, icons, orthodoxies, and pieties of the post-9/11 era. Rees doesn't just slaughter America's sacred cows--he drops a nuclear bomb on them. GYWO2 could serve as a scalding counterbalance to the many inspirational and heroic narratives that have been spun from the Global War on Terror. For a great companion text I recommend "Weapons of Mass Deception: The Uses of Propaganda in Bush's War on Iraq," by Sheldon Rampton and John Stauber.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
21 of 22 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Funnier than . . ., September 30, 2004
This review is from: Get Your War On II (Paperback)
. . . a bagfull of monkeys drafting foreign policy. And the most straightforward political commentary since Tom Paine. On speed. If you have even one cynical bone in your body (you know -- that sense of slightly defeatist but NOT defeat-ED humor that's produced when you actually perceive the breadth of incredible social possibility utterly pulped by realpolitik "reality"), GET THIS BOOK. You will laugh 'till you pee. And you'll register to vote again the very next day. Three times, probably.
Guarantee it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No