Most Helpful Customer Reviews
14 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Dickens Comes To Life, October 18, 2004
This review is from: The Ghost of Dickens' Past (DVD)
I came across this movie quite by accident and I'm sure glad I did! Being a student of Dickens and Victorian England in general, this film has to be one of the most accurate portrayals of 1840's London that I have seen. It's as if someone took a camera and found a portal into the past! The clothing and hair styles are perfect for the time period represented (1843), as is the old time dialogue spoken. Also, the actors portraying Charles and Catherine Dickens have done their homework. Compare old paintings of the two to their filmed counterparts here. Quite astounding!
The storyline itself is rather entertaining, although only having partial truth. It is more of a ghostly little tale built around a spirit-like mature young girl guiding Dickens through experiences (memories) that eventually gives the author the idea of writing his famed "A Christmas Carol" story. It shows the period when his latest novel, Martin Chuzzlewit, was not selling so well and, because of this frustration, words seemingly do not come to him for the writing of a new novel. But, through a series of almost other worldly circumstances, the girl shows Mr. Dickens how to search himself and the world about him to find the premise for his next story. The fact that Dickens was down on his financial luck before writing "Carol" is true. And, I know that his idea of the story line did not come about in quite the way this movie tells it. But that's fine - the movie itself doesn't claim to be a biography. But there are many factual biographical scenes here, such as the long walks through London at night, the way he spoke to himself as he wrote, and how he laughed out loud and cried as he completed each chapter to 'A Christmas Carol.'
Lots of truth - lots of fiction. Very enjoyable.
Since it's not truly a Christmas film per se, it's an excellent movie to watch in late October or early November, when it's too early to pull out your Holiday movies. It's a very enjoyable family flick that not only entertains, but has the values that seem to be missing in so many of today's films without being overly preachy.
If I had to pick one inaccuracy it would be the Christmas time snow falling with trees full of leaves!
By the way, this movie was filmed not in Merry Old England, but in Canada! I would never have known.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Great Story Behind THE Story, November 6, 2009
This review is from: The Ghost of Dickens' Past (DVD)
I found this movie in a local pawn shop, tucked away among hundreds of others.
I was first attracted by the title and then also by seeing the company who distributes and still sell this film, Feature Films For Families. We have bought dvds from them in the past and have never been disappointed. Unfortunately, the dvd sat on the shelf in my library for almost a year before I took the time to watch it. Let me tell you I was NOT disappointed!! You know that when you've watched a really good movie you are left with feeling pleasantly entertained. And you have seen a well crafted story that has left you feeling that your life has been enriched in some small way for having seen it.
The quality of the acting, the script, and the filming has not been compromised in any way by the fact this was an independently produced movie! If you enjoy watching the Christmas Carol every year, I HIGHLY recommend this "story behind the story"! It is a film that can be enjoyed by the entire family!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Review of Ghost of DIckens Past By Rachel Swift, Andrew McBride, Sarah McDonald, Joey Sanchez, and Devin Bergquist, December 12, 2007
This review is from: The Ghost of Dickens' Past (DVD)
The Ghost of Dickens' Past
The Ghost of Dickens' Past is a very heartwarming depiction of Dickens' inspiration and struggles in writing his beloved novel, A Christmas Carol. Altogether, the movie portrayed the time period accurately. This was done through the use of costumes, scenery, and language of the characters. The characters all wore 18th century style clothing, with the men wearing knickers and button-up shirts and the women wearing time-appropriate dresses. The language used in the movie was all Old English and the scenery accurately portrayed an old English town. Also, the movie incorporated many experiences of Dickens' life, including his parents being in debtors' prison, his speech to the laborers, his fear of being poor, his having to work as a child, and his visits to orphanages. The Ghost of Dickens' Past is, overall, entertaining for the genre of movie. It's entertainment value comes from the ability for the viewer to relate to the story of A Christmas Carol. For example, when the idea of the ghost character was realized, the viewer could relate that to the well known ghost that appears in A Christmas Carol.
There were many themes brought out in The Ghost of Dickens' Past. Charity was the biggest theme, with many other supporting themes. Through Dickens' reluctance to give money at an orphanage, it is implied that it does no good to give a gift grudgingly. Another important message that was conveyed was that doing things for the wrong reason can often impair us from accomplishing great achievements. This was shown through Dickens' inability to write a great novel because he was doing it for selfish reasons and for his own personal gain, and not for the greater good of mankind. These themes all connected to the greater theme of charity which culminated towards the end of the movie when Dickens overcomes his selfish motives and gives assistance to a poor, homeless family. After he had this life changing event, he was able to write the timeless classic favorite that has been enjoyed across the generations.
Rachel Swift
Andrew McBride
Sarah McDonald
Joey Sanchez
Devin Bergquist
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|