From Publishers Weekly
Amid the grab bag of discursive forms that make up Gerstler's eighth collection, single anecdotes animate several poems, as when a speaker misreads an offer for "Beethoven's Complete Symphonies" as "Beethoven's Complete Sympathies" and indulges in the not-so-surprising riff: "This immortal/ master... has not forgotten those left behind/ to endure gridlock and mind-ache,/ wearily crosshatching the earth's surface/ with our miseries...." Gerstler has a bit of a Billy Collins problem, writing poems that tussle with, but never quite extend, intentionally light premises that conceal serious subjects: domestic life, evolution and chronic stagnation, magic and the supernatural. In "Touring the Doll Hospital," for instance, the speaker asks, "Why so many senseless injuries?" and a few lines later, sighs, "Small soldiers with no Geneva Convention to protect them...." Such jokes tend to sink pieces in which some version of the spirit world is invoked: "Witch Songs" refers to an "invitation/ written in semen and ashâ"/ can't we just reply in ink?" while, "The Oracle at Delphi, Reincarnated as a Contemporary Adolescent Girl," begins, "I'm high most of the time on hallucinogenic fumes." Often, one doubts the poet's own investment in particular poems. What to make of a long catalogue, "Fuck You Poem #45," which reads like an undergraduate exercise: "Fuck you in slang and conventional English./ Fuck you in lost and neglected lingoes./ Fuck you hungry and sated; faded, pock marked and defaced./ Fuck you with orange rind, fennel and anchovy paste." While the collection's formal heterogeneity is refreshing, too many of the pieces here feel tossed off.
Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Funny, mischievous, and wry, Gerstler is technically skilled, profoundly curious, often bemused, inventive, and playful. Were she part of a constellation of poets, her neighbors would include Albert Goldbarth, Denise Duhamel, and Kim Addonizio, even as she whirls alone within her own glowing aura, alternating between deeply carnal considerations of food and sexuality and contemplations of such otherworldly manifestations as ghosts, oracles, and mediums. Gerstler's take on femaleness is appropriately spiky and her attunement to animal consciousness clever. She is piquant and creepy in a poem about dolls inviting abuse and stand-up-comic hilarious in a riff on the query, "And what, praytell, were you wearing?" and a poem based on her misreading of a CD offer for "Beethoven's Complete Sympathies." Elsewhere Gerstler, the author of a half-dozen distinctive collections, including
Medicine (2000), contemplates such classic predicaments as lost love and unexpected widowhood, veers into biblical themes, and saucily yet incisively observes, "Who's to say celestial insight can't ride / into the mind on a forkful of sour cherry pie?"
Donna SeamanCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved