Customer Reviews

Gideon's People

5 star:		(1)
4 star:		(2)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

The book is good, but beware the message of the children's rejection of their religious heritage. Both the Amish and the Jewish religions are shown to be strict and both are rejected by boy's seeking freedom. Both boys find family or friends who support their decision.

Isaac, 12, is recuperating in the home of an Amish family in Pennsylvania Dutch country early in the 1900's. His Jewish background conflicts seriously with that of his Amish hosts. Of particular problem is diet, and observation of the Sabbath. He quickly learns of the conflict between 16 yr. old Gideon and his father.

Both young men struggle with the regulations and restrictions of their respective families. Gideon, however, is determinded to follow his dream of reading and playing music. This will mean he has to leave his family and his beloved sister, Annie. Annie seems to be a central character in this book, both for Gideon and for Isaac. She shows incredible insight and compassion.

This book deals with family conflict, religious traditions and the interactions of youth from different cultures. It might be more appropriate for the older child, since it does deal with some serious rejecting of the beliefs of the parents and needs to be discussed within a safe and informative environment such as the home first.

This book shows are people of all different races can get along I think that it is wonderful book.