Most Helpful Customer Reviews
6 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A great band's potential fully realized, October 1, 2001
It's hard for me to give any Jam album less than five stars...they are, after all, one of my favorite bands. Paul Weller, before forming the Style Council and eventually going on to a solo career, was the singer/songwriter/guitarist for this influential mod/punk trio that was enormously successful in their native England but never really hit it off in the States. As their albums progressed, Weller began moving the band further away from straight punk and into more R&B-flavored territory. Here are the ultimate fruits of that transformation. Along with the influence of Motown ("Town Called Malice"), this album also includes tasteful nods to disco ("Precious"), along with a more mod/punk call to their ealier days ("Just Who Is the Five O'Clock Hero"), an interesting instrumental track ("Circus)" and catchy numbers like "Happy Together" and "Ghosts." Further evidence of experimentation is evident on the dancey "Trans-Global Express" and the use of steel drums on "Planner's Dream Gone Wrong." Unfortunately, Weller disbanded the group soon afterwards, but in a way it's a good thing -- quitting at their peak was the classiest thing these guys could have done. Highly, highly recommended.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
7 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A band that refused to run on the spot...., June 28, 2000
I'll plump for 'Sound Affects' as the Jam's best album, but although 'The Gift' is a flawed work there is an emotional intensity about many of the tracks that appeals. Particularly the first three - 'Happy Together' (which, with the constant 'Fa-fa-fa' backing vocals on several songs seems to be an oblique nod to US sixties band The Turtles) is sardonic; while 'Ghosts' and 'Precious ' have some of Weller's best ever lyrics. 'Running on the Spot' and 'Carnation' are in a similar vein - intense and emotional. And, likewise, one is highly personal, the other seems to reflect Weller's social concerns. At the time the album was released I could never get past the fact that 'A Town Called Malice' sounds rather too like the Supremes' 'Can't Hurry Love'. It's grown on me a bit now, but still.....Elsewhere 'Just Who is the Five O'Clock Hero' and 'Planners Dream Went Wrong' sound like a Ken Loach or Mike Leigh movie set to music. The former is a great track, the latter just, well, goes wrong...The remaining tracks don't really work, for this reviewer anyway. But the explosive intensity of the remainder are enough to warrant four stars. And I always take my hat off to an artist who is not satisfied with repeating a previously successful formula, but who pushes the creative envelope and tries new things. For that, (rare in rock music in the early 1980s, seemingly non-existent now ) the occasional miss is forgivable.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Goobye Jam,Hello....Style Council?, August 4, 2003
Paul Weller is ready for a big musical change.While on "The Gift" Weller and The Jam deliver some typically catchy, sponanious Brit pop like "Happy Together","Ghosts" and "Running On the Spot",much of this album seriously attempts to blend in heavy funk,jazz,Carribean and even African styled music into The Jam's framework.This approch doesn't always succeed entirely but on numbers like the Sly Ston-ish "Trans-Global Express",the bombastic afro-funk of "Precious" and the classic,almost ready -made Motown beat of the classic "Town Called Malice".While the Jam effectively pull off the diverse songwritng assignments and add in punchy horn charts,it's clear Weller was proven right- the guitar-based Jam simply wern't the band to make this kind of music consistantly and while they're all fantastic musicians in their own right,Weller was wise to try something new next time around with a new band to work with.But that doesn't take anything away from this fun,bouncy album!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|