Most Helpful Customer Reviews
16 of 16 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Flawless Craftsman at Work, February 22, 2001
This review is from: Gift Of Stones (Paperback)
I was unfamiliar with Crace before reading this muted narrative in the voice of one who survives awful and awesome economic hardship, wrought by technological change. I intend to make more of his acquaintance. The setting is pre-Roman Britain in a community prospering because of its unsurpassed working of flint. The story centers on a man who loses a limb as a child and must survive on the contemptible outside of his people's working world . He becomes a superb story-teller using skills of an unrivalled social observer and even what today would be called a "futurist". He carefully watches and records, through semi-fictional stories, all the subtle as well as obvious forces inexorably gathering to undercut his people's world. For this is the dawn of the Bronze Age when that material would far outperform the best of the stonemasons' product. And so their world falls apart. But, using the skills he has had to hone because of being a misfit for so long, he finds a way to survive. This, we are left feeling, may be the sole legacy that transcends the vagaries of economic change. For those who can tell good (not necessarily true) stories of the past are sometimes the only ones whose understanding is enough to tell a story in the future tense, to, in essence, invent the future. No one can say what that world was really like back then and thereby comment on how validly Crace depicts this long gone era. Yet I felt transported and that the sense of those unrecorded times was powerfully captured. Validity, who knows? Propinquity? For sure. Crace has built so very different a world yet one, which we feel familiar with, indeed, even at home in. I would commend this fine book to anyone but especially those who believe that ours is an age of never-before experienced turbulence and uncertainty. Just as Barbara Tuchman did in "A Distant Mirror" but this time using fiction, Jim Crace disabuses us of the presumptuous idea that we bear heavier crosses than our long passed ancestors. Economic transition is never easy and this is an absorbing account of how it feels from the inside.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
14 of 16 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Change, September 16, 2001
This review is from: Gift Of Stones (Paperback)
"The Gift Of Stones", is the second novel written by Jim Crace. He tells this story through a storyteller he created from the notes of Sir Henry Penn Butler in, "Memoirs of an Excavationist circa 1927". Evidently while pursuing old stone implements they came upon the bones from a lower arm of a child. Mr. Crace has done as they did the evening of their find when they sat around their fire and spun tales of why the bones were there, and where the balance of the bones were to be found. Mr. Crace took the same bit of information and created a remarkable work that is about change. The change is this book is not unlike the changes faced today. A fundamental shift in knowledge can have dramatic and even catastrophic effects on a people. And this is the tale of, The Gift Of Stones". At some point most have read about the implements of The Stone Age, and also the dramatic changes that were brought about by the advent of bronze. Many have perhaps learned of this change through textbooks and classes in history. Jim Crace has told the same story of change as it might have been seen through the eyes of those who were dependent upon stone for their way of life. From the mention of the bones from a child's lower arm, he recreates history as he creates a wonderful novel. The community of stoneworkers is recreated with marvelous detail about the methods used in creating stone implements. The descriptions go far beyond the crude instruments hacked from the blows of another stone. The author illustrates the artisans these people were with a stoneworker nicknamed, "the Leaf". Here was an artisan who would keep on his workbench a leaf as produced by nature, and use it both as inspiration and an item of beauty he would seek to emulate in his work. The craftsmen in this book are treated more like skilled sculptors/artists, than the makers of crude tools. The author creates a circle with the flight of an arrow creating the basis for his story, and yet another arrow that brings everything to an end. The second arrow is of course fashioned from bronze, and it is an arrow that can kill much more than an animal or a man. It brings complete destruction to a way of life, to what is also referred to as an age. As he has done before Jim Crace is able to take a subject that is not unfamiliar, and recast the ideas to create a read that is new and unique.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
10 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The nature of storytelling explored, September 21, 2002
This review is from: Gift Of Stones (Paperback)
This short novel ruminates on a number of very interesting themes in an unusual way. It is a book about the nature of stories, the nature of people, and the ways that we think about ancient peoples. Most of all, though, it makes the reader think about how change affects individuals and groups ... all through the story of a young man and his daughter. If a book about the stone age conjures images of The Clan of the Cave Bear for you, then wipe it from your mind before starting this. The Gift of Stones starts from a simple premise: an archaeologist has found the amputated arm bone of a young boy, and he and his colleagues imagine what must have been his life. This young man also imagines lives, and tells those stories, much to the delight of his village. His daughter carries on the tradition as the true narrative voice of the book. I had never read any of Crace's work before this slim volume, but I've already gone out to buy all of them. He is a wonderful writer without over-writing or involving himself in senseless wordplay. If you are looking for a thought-provoking story with memorable characters, then this book is definitely for you.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|