22 of 22 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Haunting battle of wills, February 26, 2003
Jane Yolen and Robert J. Harris serve up a worthy successor to "Queen's Own Fool": "Girl in a Cage," the second of four historical novels taking place during pivotal parts of Scottish history. "Girl" is a great read, funny and chilling and taking readers right into the middle of Scotland during the time of Robert the Bruce.
As the book opens, Marjorie Bruce is being dragged by English soldiers to a small town, where she is tossed into an animal's cage. The villagers treat her with disgust, and she is kept under guard. Her life was turned upside-down when her father confronted and killed Red Comyn, a treacherous lackey of King Edward Longshanks. Now Marjorie's father, Robert the Bruce, has been crowned king of Scotland, and Longshanks is trying to hunt down and kill him.
In flashback, Marjorie reveals the events that turned herself, her stepmother, and her relations into fugitives. In the present, the dying Longshanks visits Marjorie's cage to taunt her, pressing the lonely girl to betray her father in exchange for release. And Marjorie, crown princess of Scotland, is determined to outlast the enemy king, no matter what.
Usually flashbacks stink. But Harris and Yolen pull it off wonderfully, flipping between the past and the present. And even though in the present Marjorie never budges from her cage, there are all sorts of little subplots, such as some peasant children who become her "knights" and "ladies-in-waiting," or the kindly monk who tries to help her in small ways.
Marjorie's character development is absolutely wonderful; at the beginning of the whole adventure, she's a bit immature and petulant. But her rude awakening when she is treated like less than an animal is well-drawn, and her iron-clad determination to outlast Longshanks. Speaking of Longshanks, he is presented as a pretty vile person, but not two-dimensionally so -- one very striking scene near the end has him talking about his dead wife.
The writing isn't too wrapped up in historical details the way most historical novels are. And as with "Fool," Yolen and Harris are careful with the very complex politics of the times. They make all this easy to understand, but never dumbed-down. The descriptions of Marjorie's misery in the cage is haunting.. And the last chapters are incredibly powerful, with Marjorie's last talk with Longshanks and a very unexpected twist. (Whatever it is, you won't expect it)
Adults and kids alike can read "Girl in a Cage" -- like "Fool," it's one of those fantastic historical books that will be as good for any age group, especially for people who love Scotland.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
9 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
My Favorite Historical Fiction Book, May 20, 2005
A Kid's Review
Girl in a Cage is about how a Scottish princess, Margerie Bruce, is taken prisoner by King Longshanks of England. It is set in both England and Scotland in about 1347. It tells about what Margerie's father did to become king, what happened to her so that she became a prisoner, and what happened during her prisoner ship. It is a great page turner and leaves you at the end of each chapter with cliffhangers that make you want to read it forever. How the author describes the time that Margerie lived in a cage is awesome. Also a lot of it is true. The author did a lot of research and it turned out great. It also shows a great deal of how King Longshanks (a character who is actually king Edward) treated his prisoners. I think that this was one of the best historical fiction books that I have ever read and would recommend it to anyone.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
8 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Thrilled To Be A Princess, December 10, 2005
Girl In A Cage is an okay book, and it's about a wealthy Scottish girl named Marjorie during the time of 1306. Things between her country and the English have not been going well. England plans to invade Scotland, but Marjorie's father Robert the Bruce will not let their enemy do so. With much appoval, Robert the Bruce crowns himself as King of Scotland, and then draws plans to lead men against the invaders. Despite the constant threat, Marjorie is thrilled to be a princess, however her happiness is lived short. The English soon enters Scotland's borders, and thus King Robert calls for war. England declares little mercy for those who defy them, even women, so Majorie must flee for her life, being the only heir of the King of Scotland. But then she is captured in a cage. She is imprisoned for a town square's public display in England. Marjorie must deal with cold, hunger, little privacy, in addition to the cruel mockings of the townspeople. She must also face the King of England, her captor, whose harsh words make her fear for the fate of her family, and the fate of Scotland itself. Nevertheless, Marjorie still remains strong. She does not have a sword, and is not in a bloody battlefield, but she can still wage a war. Marjorie will win the battle against all extremities, for she is not only a Princess by her father, but a Princess by heart.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No