27 of 27 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Wish it felt more familiar, October 13, 2011
This review is from: Girl in the Kitchen: How a Top Chef Cooks, Thinks, Shops, Eats and Drinks (Hardcover)
Stephanie Izard is a huge talent and is one of the best chefs on the scene today. I was super excited about this cookbook after eating at Girl and the Goat, where my friend and I had one of the best dining experiences of our lives.
My disappointment probably stems from my own assumptions about what the book would contain -- after all, it's true that it DOES NOT say that it contains recipes from Girl and the Goat. So this review is just to warn others who may erroneously assume, as I did, that the book would contain recipes for some of the wonderful dishes that are served at Stephanie's Chicago restaurant.
I never thought it would include the recipe for Pig Face, as braising an entire hog's head would be daunting for the average home cook, but I *was* hoping for her recipe for sauteed green beans, which are out of this world. Since I don't live in Chicago, I was looking forward to possibly being able to duplicate at home part of my wonderful experience at Girl and the Goat.
I was also rather dismayed to find that Stephanie's website contains many -- if not all -- of the recipes found in this book. While certainly I enjoy a beautiful cookbook (which it is) that I can keep on the shelf with the rest of my cookbook collection, I kind of felt that I had paid for what was essentially free content on the web. Then again, the same can be said of the Pioneer Woman's cookbook, so your mileage may vary on whether or not this is something that would bother you.
All that said, I am looking forward to trying many of the recipes found in the book; Stephanie seems to have a fantastic grasp of flavors and comes up with dishes that have almost universal palate appeal.
Edit on 10/31/2011: I had the pleasure of meeting Stephanie at a book signing recently and she conveyed two pieces of information that I found useful and might be interesting to others who are thinking of purchasing this book. First, she revealed that the recipe for her fan favorite green beans is actually "secretly" in the book! It was originally conceived as a recipe for English peas -- so if you take that recipe from this book, sub the peas for fresh green beans, then add cashews and sliced shallots, you have the G&tG green beans. :D Full disclosure though, I checked the recipe afterward and it doesn't seem 'complete.' At the restaurant, they also drizzle some sort of opaque white sauce over them, which the English peas recipe doesn't have... not sure how big a difference that makes. The second piece of info is that she IS actually working on a restaurant cookbook from G&tG, so there's also that to look forward to!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Where's The Pigface?, February 3, 2012
This review is from: Girl in the Kitchen: How a Top Chef Cooks, Thinks, Shops, Eats and Drinks (Hardcover)
I saw Stephanie Izard featured on the 'Rosie' show, and Rosie was wild about her food. I collect cookbooks and thought this would be a great addition. Izard has also appeared on the 'Top Chef'.
There are over one hundred recipes in 'The Girl in the Kitchen' and they sound delicious. Izard gives us a 'flavor profile of ingredients and their effect on the overall dish', and she explains what they mean. Also, every couple of pages she provides a
'feature ingredient spotlight'. Some of these ingredients are not the everyday kind you would find in your regular supermarket. There is an opening chapter where Stephanie explains her philosophy and training. The book is separated by chapters starting with 'Starters'-asian inspired english peas, looks great. Onto 'Soups' and Pumpkin-Cod Soup- wow! Chapter THree is 'salads', including 'Shrimp, corn and green tomato'. Pastas follows in chapter four and my favorite is 'four cheese macaroni with apples and bacon'. Chapter five is 'Mains' and 'soft shelled crab sandwiches' looks so good! 'Sides' is chapter six and 'roasted fingerlings with picada' caught my eye. The last chapter is 'Extras'and salsa verde caught my eye.
This is a beautifully photographed book, and the cookbook is so well done. However, I am disappointed. The recipes are quite electic, and the only one I might attempt is the beef stew. I will read the cookbook again, and see what I can garner that might fit my family.
Recommended. prisrob 02-03-12
How to Cook Like a Top Chef
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
So far so good, October 11, 2011
This review is from: Girl in the Kitchen: How a Top Chef Cooks, Thinks, Shops, Eats and Drinks (Hardcover)
Made the stew last night and it was amazing. Best stew I have ever had and I can't wait to try more recipes.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No