From School Library Journal
Grade 3-5-A dozen brief stories mimic the flavor of traditional tales, with none of the meat. They are undeveloped in theme, plot, and character, leaving readers unsatisfied and bewildered. For example, in the title selection, a shepherdess makes friends with the coyotes, who kill and eat one of her sheep. Then, to escape her boring life, the girl runs off to live with the coyotes. The remaining tales seem similarly unconnected, rambling, and motiveless. Bryer's pictures, however, are luscious and savory. Each primitive painting is full of color, detail, and action, framed with borders containing designs of rugs, tinwork, feathers, birds, animals, and plants. The artist has taken the traditional devices of the Southwest and made them her own. The same is not true for Wood's stories. Too bad, as the stunning art deserves attention.
Ruth Semrau, formerly at Lovejoy School, Allen, TXCopyright 1995 Reed Business Information, Inc.
Ages 5 and up. As Wood notes in her preface, the coyote is "the embodiment of the great [American] Southwestern spirit, surviving against impossible odds." In many of these 12 original stories, the coyote is a central figure of survival amid the clash of Indian, Spanish, and Anglo cultures. The title story launches the book's exploration of conflict. When a sheepherder's daughter watches a pack of coyotes eat one of her father's sheep, she cries, "Those are my father's sheep!" and a coyote replies, "It's our nature to eat sheep." Sympathetic to the coyotes, the girl flees with the pack and is said to be heard singing with them every new moon. The stories vary greatly, but all are compellingly written, inventive, and tinged with mysticism and melancholy over an environment scarred by warring human interests. The striking, oil-on-linen illustrations also convey a complexity of viewpoint. Both primitive and ornate, traditional and contemporary, the paintings somehow wrestle the southwestern cliches of cactus and howling coyotes into emblems of great dignity.
Julie Yates Walton