I approached the indie "Girlfriend" with some trepidation. As the central protagonist is a young man with Down Syndrome, I was worried that the movie might be overly sentimental or would strain for uplift as sometimes these well meaning endeavors attempt. I was pleasantly surprised, therefore, that this was NOT a movie about Down Syndrome. Instead, it happens to be a film in which the lead character is living with Down. And even more refreshing, he's flawed and frustrating and embodies a three dimensional character with foibles, poor judgement, and the expected complexities of a young man struggling toward adulthood. In his first full length feature, writer/director Justin Lerner has established a movie that feels simultaneously real and offbeat. And while I wasn't entirely convinced throughout the plot, the characters felt so grounded that I was swept up in this unusual tale.
"Girlfriend" introduces us to Evan (Evan Sneider, who is Down in real life) who shares a comfortable rural existence with his mother (the great Amanda Plummer. Where has she gone? Why don't we see her more often?). Evan is a sociable enough individual who yearns for normalcy. He works in the restaurant industry with this mom, he tries to keep up with high school friends, he crushes on a girl (Raising Hope's Shannon Woodward) and gets caught up in the drama, intrigue, and romance of his favorite TV programs. More than anything, though, he just wants to have a girl by his side and his sights are set on Woodward. Things take a turn when Evan is left on his own, and he attempts to get closer to his dream girl by rescuing her from dire financial straits. This squarely gets him caught up in a complicated domestic situation that also involves her former flame (Jackson Rathbone) and her young son. The screenplay isn't, at time, afraid to make Evan unlikable which is much to its credit. Just who, if anyone, is taking advantage of whom? Some might describe this as a gentle love story (and in its way, it is) but I was far more intrigued by the weightier moral decisions its characters faced.
Sneider does well in a challenging role. Woodward is solid enough, and Rathbone is charmingly unhinged. I really thought this movie was exceedingly well acted and involving. Sometimes, however, the situations strained credibility. I won't reveal any spoilers, I'll just say that I never fully bought Evan's financial independence (which was established rather haphazardly with a convenient wad of cash). The movie, after being so good, doesn't seem to know how to end as well. A sudden and inexplicable accident feels both rushed and tacked on. Seriously, I was so engrossed that I thought I was going to give the movie my highest recommendation. But these stumbles, especially at the end, disappointed me more than I'd like to admit. Still, though, I wholeheartedly recommend "Girlfriend." It's not a movie I feel like I've seen a dozen times before and this originality goes a long way with me. I look forward to Lerner's next project. KGHarris, 7/12.