12 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
READ this book!, July 26, 2000
By A Customer
This review is from: The Glory Field (Mass Market Paperback)
I am not, and never have been, much of a history buff. In fact, it was my least favorite subject throughout school. Therefore, I never expected to enjoy reading The Glory Field.... but I did! Incredibly, I have to say, it is by far one of THE BEST books I've ever read. I immediately found myself drawn into the lives of the characters; wondering which of them would make it, and which ones would not. I'd sit down to read "a few pages", and find myself still reading an hour later. Myers paints a vivid picture of the black slaves' life: their commitment to family, their never-ending belief in God, and their struggle for freedom...and survival. He takes the reader on the journey of a lifetime...from the trip over from Africa on the crowded slave ship, through the days of back-breaking labor in the fields, through the civil rights movement, to the glorious days of owning their own land. The reader finds himself unable to put the book down, connected to this family's journey, and struggling along with them for what's right. My advice: READ this book! Teachers, read it to your students. Moms & Dads, read it to your children. Read it for yourself. You'll be glad you did, and a little more grateful for what you have.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
16 of 18 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Simply not my type, February 27, 2000
This review is from: The Glory Field (Mass Market Paperback)
I very much enjoy books that deal with ethnicity and self-discovery. And I'm beginning to enjoy American history at least a little (world history has always held my attention; the United States only has 200 years to work with, see what I mean?).
I could find, however, nothing incredible or amazing about this book. It is typical. Some scenes are mediocre, some are less than mediocre, very few truly caught my interest. Myers' gift (which probably isn't nonexistent, since "Fallen Angels" is quite popular) manifests in the areas of this book that are broad and well-known. I could have written a book of this ilk. All I would have needed to know would be something about slavery, something about the Great Depression. And that's all.
"The Glory Field" seemed to lack detail, and another element which I can't quite put my finger on, but must have something to do with making the novel fall together, into one cohesive tale (with many strands woven into it, characterized by the many family members). Ahhhh...characterized, huh? Well, I could not relate to any of the characters in this book -- I was forced to stretch the truth at school, when on a daily quiz the teacher asked, "Which character could you most relate to?"
I answered Lizzy. I lied.
My history teacher, a very well-read woman who makes everything fall into place, makes everything interesting, once showed us a video on American slavery. It truly was painful to watch. It showed slaves, men and women, scarred, children with faces mature beyond their years. If "The Glory Field" had handled some of these grisly elements -- perhaps not physically, since this is, after all an 8th grade book (and people seem to think my kind are stupid, immature, and can't take reality as it comes), but mentally (Lizzy was there, Lizzy did this, but did Lizzy really think much running away, besides, "I am afraid. But I am elated because I will be free" or about Lem's death and her subsequet marriage to Lem's brother Richard, or about Miss Julia's pampering -- (while Lizzy was thinking about flouncing about Johnson City in white gowns I kept thinking about her being slapped by Miss Julia on one occasion) -- , etc, etc).
Mohammad Bilal's role, also, was not expanded upon. This was somewhat of a relief (I still remember the incredibly boring 6th grade book "Amos Fortune: Free Man"), but later, a disappointment. Where were the people, behind the cardboard cuttout images of American cliches?
The slips in years would have been more tolerable if they characters were realistic, more poignant if the characters were likable (forget realism, then, let's go for liking 'em, Mr. Myers!).
All in all, a passable book... It makes me think, 'Well, if this book got published, I can publish one of my own books, right?' Now, you tell me, is that good or bad? <g>
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
8 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Thanks Mom!, June 25, 2004
It was my mom that suggested I read this and boy oh boy I'm glad she did!
Myers goes from generation to generation talking about this one black family--all the way from when they got off the slave ship in the south to living in New York in 1994.
When I first picked up the giant book, I just knew it would be boring. But once I read the first chapter, I just knew it would be interesting.
There area a lot of powerful things in this book and the language is strong (but not in a provocative way) so, I advise only mature readers to read this.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No