This is a good read for someone who is already a fan of the Gluten-Free Girl blog and enjoys reading about her personal experiences, life and food philosophy, and positive outlook on Celiac Disease. Although I like the blog and the author's literary persona, I'm afraid this book did not satisfy my desire for a gourmet gluten-free cookbook. There are some recipes sprinkled throughout the book, and many of them sound (and probably are) quite good. However, the true test of a gluten-free chef is really their bread products. There are only a few baked carbohydrate recipes in this book, including a sorghum bread, pizza, and pie crust. Tonight I tried the promising recipe for Crusty Sorghum Bread in the hopes that quality of recipe would replace quantity and I could enjoy a great gluten-free artisan's bread recipe. Halfway through making the recipe, I was a bit astonished to find that the main liquid ingredient in the recipe, club soda, had no quantity listed. The instructions just said to add "as much as is needed to wet all the ingredients completely." Further, at that point the dough should be "soft and firm, like a baby's bottom." Descriptive and lyrical though that is, I had no idea exactly HOW wet the dough should be. I'm an experienced gluten-free baker, but gluten-free dough can have VERY different textures before being baked. Sometimes they are very wet, like cake batter, and other times the dough is much drier. And I can only imagine that the instructions would be even more confusing to someone NOT used to how weird gluten-free baking can be. I found several strange things about the recipe that in retrospect should have warned me that it might not be the kind of loaf I was hoping for. The author tells the reader not to be too optimistic about the bread's rising, because "no gluten exists to stimulate its rising." Later, she says "at the end of the evening, slice up any remaining bread and put it into the freezer. Gluten-free bread usually turns rock hard the next day." (130) Anyone who has made Bette Hagman's bread recipes knows that gluten-free bread CAN rise to the extent that it doubles or triples in size, even, with miscalculation, overflowing out of the pan. Further, those same bread recipes actually do not turn rock hard the next day- they stay just as soft as when you made them for several days until either mold or dryness gets the best of them, depending on your climate. I thought perhaps since this book was written to inspire newly diagnosed individuals, the gluten-free girl was trying to manage expectations and make sure no one would be disappointed. So, I persevered and finished out the recipe, trusting that some of the oddities (using the bread dough hook that is generally always avoided in gluten-free baking, letting the dough half rise and then changing it to another container etc.) were perhaps informed by the chef's training and might pay off in unexpected ways. At last, the loaf of bread was finished. It didn't look exactly like the artisan's loaf I'd imagined but it did have something of a crust and easily came out of the Dutch oven. Ten minutes later I sliced it, as instructed, and served my partner a slice with butter and tried some myself. The first thing I thought was that it tasted very gluten-free. The taste of the baking soda was also quite strong, making the recipe seem more like a quick bread than the more sophisticated yeast bread recipe it was. I have been eating gluten-free bread a long time, so I was not comparing the flavor to gluten breads. Compared to the gluten-free breads that I usually enjoy (such as the soft, whole grain loaves by Bette Hagman) this bread tasted more like a healthy gluten-free muffin than gourmet bread. I thought perhaps my partner would enjoy the bread. Although they can eat gluten and do, they are used to trying out gluten-free breads that I make, and I always solicit their opinion. Unfortunately, even lathered in butter, they didn't want to eat it after the first bite.... and generally they have the first slice of gluten-free bread and ask for more. I was terribly disappointed because I had very high expectations and really expected to enjoy the star bread recipe of the book. My fear is that newly diagnosed readers who try the bread will really end up thinking that gluten-free bread can't rise, and that they have to resign themselves to bread that doesn't last longer than a night. I would like to assure those readers that gluten-free bread can and does do both of those things. Please find inspiration in the Gluten-Free Girl's attitude towards life and positivity- but if you are looking simply for a gluten-free cookbook and seeking bread recipes you can make the staples in your household, this may not be the book for you. I hope that if there is anyone who reads this review that has tried this bread recipe and enjoyed it more than other homemade gluten-free bread recipes, they will post comments to that effect. I think it is important to review the recipes as well as the literary artistry in a book like this, and I hope that some readers will find this review and any follow-up comments useful.
