Most Helpful Customer Reviews
13 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Back to what they do best., February 12, 2000
This review is from: God Save the Smithereens (Audio CD)
After the colossal failure that was A Date With The Smithereens, which all but killed the band, the Smithereens have returned to what they do best: writing two and three minute songs that reek of their influences (Buddy Holly, the Beatles, and the Kinks). Which is great, for this is the formula that brought them their greatest success (although modest) in the 80's, before they felt the inclination to turn everything up to 11 in the studio in order to compete with the Seattle movement. Unfortunately, the five year silence (longer if you want to totally dismiss DWTS) between records cost them all but their most fervent fans, and the chances of regaining past commercial success are slim to none, due to radio's current taste for garbage. This is really an album for Smithereens fans only, one of those "great little secret" kind of records. If you haven't been a fan since the beginning (like I have), chances are this won't end up in your collection. But if you didn't happen to be around during their peak years('86 to '91), actually like British Invasion type melodies from an American band, and have an open mind about music whose taste spans generations, then this record has much more than enough to satisfy. Thus I highly recommend it. There are two many great songs here to mention, but the absolute gems here are: "She's Got A Way", "Everything Changes", 'Flowers In the Blood", "Gloomy Sunday", "I Believe", "Even If I Never Get Back Home", "Try", and "The Last Good Time". If you end up liking what you hear here, then buy (immediately) the first three albums: Especially For You, Green Thoughts, and 11. And if you have an opportunity to see the Smithereens do it live, do not miss that chance, no matter what. I saw them here in September (outdoors on a rainy evening, no less), and they sounded as great as ever. I hope to see them many more times in the coming years. Long live the Smithereens!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
14 of 16 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Worth the buy for the bonus tracks - still great years later, February 28, 2005
The Smithereens have decided to re-release "God Save the Smithereens" from 1999, as well as Pat DiNizio's "Songs and Sounds" from 1997. Both are excellent, and the latter is such a great album and didn't get a ton of press in the late 90s since it wasn't "The Smithereens" but just Pat. It became a collector's album after it was out of print for a while - not the path that it was expected to take, I'm sure.
"God Save" is also excellent, but it too faded quicker than it should have. It has been deemed (unofficially) their comeback album after 1994's "Date with" didn't do that well.
The bonus tracks in this double CD package are superb. You'll hear some songs that almost made it onto "God Save" in 1999, as well as a few alternate tracks of songs you already know. It's like having a new Smithereens record - sort of. Also some unreleased demos are included for a treat. The tracks from Pat DiNizio live in Spain are worth more than one listen. He sings Smithereens tunes on stage without the band. Apparently this is another rare album that has rarely seen the light of day, so it's nice that these songs are on this re-release. The new liner notes from Pat are worth it, too!
Die hard fans most likely already own "GSTS" and PDS&S" so it's a little bit of a downer having to buy these albums again. But just a little. Rumors of an entirely NEW album have been flying about, and it's going on 6 years since that's happened. So I'm sure I speak for many when I say that I can't wait for the day that new album comes out! This double CD is a nice treat for now.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
9 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Excellent, November 8, 2005
The Smitereens are one of the most underappreciated rock bands I have ever heard of. People just dismiss them away because they're not in their prime. Good, bluesy music. Keep up the good work.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|