6 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Ultimately disappointing and anticlimactic, May 31, 2008
"Goddess" is the third and final book in the Percheron Saga written by Fiona McIntosh. It picks up right where "Emissary" left off: Zaradine Ana has been kidnapped by rebels in the desert who have plans for her unborn child; Lazar, the Spur and protector of his adopted city of Percheron, is suffering from the Drezden poison illness after a failed trek across the desert in an attempt to prevent war; the young Zar Boaz is facing war against his city while trying to negotiate his way through the political maneuverings of his mother, Herezah, and the Grand Master Eunich, Salmeo, each of whom are trying to use him for a different agenda. At the same time, the Goddess Lyana is rising once again to do battle with the demon Maliz who defeated her centuries ago.
Ms. McIntosh sets up a story on a grand scale in the first book of the series, "Odalisque," promising political intrigue, war between nations and even a battle among gods. Unfortunately, "Goddess" doesn't really fulfill the promises made in "Odalisque," kind of fizzling out without delivering a properly satisfying ending. The promised battle between god and demon takes place over the course of a couple of pages at the very end of "Goddess," and turns out not to be a battle at all. The promised war between nations is set up fairly early in the second book, "Emissary," but ends almost before it begins. In the end, everything the author builds up to in the first two books turns out to be disappointingly anticlimactic.
Also, much of the series is bogged down by Ms. McIntosh's heavy-handedness with plot and character. Many plot devices to move the story along and keep the reader interested feel transparent and unnatural, just a means to move the story from point A to point B. In addition, the characters take quite a long time to develop fully, and some never seem to. In the first two books, the characters have their set roles and fulfill them as expected; the heroes are heroic and the villains are villainous. And it's pretty easy to tell who's who. It isn't until "Goddess" that Herezah, the mother of Zar Boaz, starts to develop some insight and a softer side, which is a nice relief from the plotting, power-hungry, lustful woman we'd come to know and despise, and Lazar, the cranky, withdrawn leader of Percheron's army, stops alternately stomping around and acting like a love-struck teenager, finally stepping up to his role as protector of Percheron and its royal family. However, many of the other characters never develop even this depth, such as Salmeo, who remains simply treacherous throughout, and Zar Boaz, a teenager who seems to be a child prodigy at ruling countries, making insightful decisions that everyone admires and behaving exactly as a model Zar should while at the same time falling rather easily into the plots centered around him. Ironically, one of the most enjoyable characters in the series turns out to Maliz, the demon trickster who has achieved eternal life through his ability to inhabit the bodies of others. He actually seems like a fun guy to hang around with, intelligent and funny and always up to something. It's almost too bad that throughout the entire trilogy he's not intelligent enough to figure out what Lyana is actually up to; despite centuries of doing battle with her and defeating her each time, she stays one step ahead of him this cycle and his end is, once again, disappointing and anticlimactic.
Also, the entire series probably could have been a hundred pages or so shorter if the characters didn't constantly rehash everything. Halfway through "Goddess," I had long since lost count of how many conversations had been held about who is or isn't the chosen reincarnation of Lyana, as one example. While it is necessary to have some purposeful misdirection, the constant dialogues and discussions and rehashing become tedious after awhile. Plus, the relatively small cast of main characters makes it obvious to the reader who is doing what to whom even during the few occasions the reader isn't privy to all of the political maneuverings that are afoot. Which also bogs the story down while the reader, who usually has inside knowledge well in advance, waits either for the plot to unfold or for one of the characters to figure out what's going on (which in many cases seems like it should be blatantly obvious even to the characters involved). This also makes for few surprises for the reader throughout the course of the story.
That being said, the setting of the series, which is a re-imagined Constantinople, provides a refreshing backdrop for the story and a nice change from the pseudo-European settings of most fantasy novels. Ms. McIntosh does a good job of making the culture and the integral role of the Zar's harem accessible, even if one doesn't necessarily buy into the idea (or practicality) of having forty or so wives and concubines.
Also, her strength in writing really seems to lie in extreme circumstances. She seems to relish the opportunity to relate all the gory details of such punishments as floggings and castrations and does so painfully well. She has a few such brutal scenes in "Odalisque," but not so many in the other two novels. There is, however, a fun fight scene toward the end of "Goddess" where Lazar takes on twenty men in a swordfight.
Also, through her ability to misdirect the reader, she does provide a few surprises throughout, despite the reader being privy to much of the ongoing political plotting and characters' thoughts. The final guise of Lyana, for example, while it makes sense, is unforeseen before it's revealed. Which, of course, should be one of the main things that keeps the reader turning pages.
All in all the Percheron Saga is a decent fantasy trilogy, which "Goddess" does a fair, but ultimately unsatisfying, job of concluding. Readers who have enjoyed J. V. Jones should enjoy it, as her writing style feels very similar, as would those relatively new to the fantasy genre, but more seasoned fantasy readers may not get as much out of it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Enjoyable reading lessened by bewildering ending..., June 4, 2008
I'm not going to rehash all of the plot details - for that, you can read the other reviews and the plot synopsis provided by Amazon.
I thoroughly enjoyed the first two books in this series, and own (and enjoyed!) all of the books Fiona McIntosh has published. I also enjoyed reading the majority of this book. Nevertheless, I found the ending to this book to be somewhat unsatisfying. The majority of the book leads to a stunning climax and then... it all just stops. The last chapter or two seem rushed, almost as though the word count for the book had been reached and someone had to put an ending into place. There doesn't seem to be much explanation for or introduction to this ending. In other words, I finished the book and said "oh."
I highly recommend the Quickening Trilogy, though, which is comprised of "Myrren's Gift", "Blood and Memory" and "Bridge of Souls".
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No