Most Helpful Customer Reviews
8 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Check out Godland!, March 16, 2006
This review is from: Godland, Vol. 1: Hello, Cosmic! (v. 1) (Paperback)
Joe Casey and Tom Scioli deliever the goods in this tale of cosmic drama that goes down like a glass of cool fresh water. If one would like a FREE full-issue preview of issues #1 and #8 they can check them out at newsarama.com. I read issue #1 and that was enough for me. Gorgeous art, smart story -telling and a "great" price for the collected trade make for a sweet deal! Who needs Infinite Crisis? Recomended!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Great for what it is ... but does it want to be more?, April 27, 2006
This review is from: Godland, Vol. 1: Hello, Cosmic! (v. 1) (Paperback)
if the intent was to produce a fun throwback to Kirby's late career - the New Gods/Kamandi/Eternals/Detroyer Duck era - while putting a little bit of a contemporary spin on the "Kirby genre," then the book is an unqualified success, in large part because of Casey's cleverness as a writer and Scioli's sincerity as an imitator/reinventor of the Kirby style. It is for this reason that I plan to read all the G?DLAND trades as they come out, personally. But I'm certain that that is not the intent - that Casey and Scioli mean to do more. There's a podcast interview on Wordballoon.com, where Casey mentions that G?DLAND is supposed to be more than a nostalgia kick, specifically pointing to the relationships between the protagonist, Adam Archer, and his sisters, as an example of the complexity and contemporary nature of the work. Yeeks. If anything, the relationships between Adam and his sisters remind me of the weak, childish characterizations you might see in any typical Silver Age comic book - there's one sequence, between Adam and his sister Neela, for example, that reminds me of the poorly-done "feminist" version of Lois Lane from the late 1960's/early 1970's (if you're not familiar with those books: the only difference between the feminist Lois and the pre-feminist Lois was that pre-feminist Lois was always grateful when Superman rescued her; feminist Lois was always pissed off by the rescue; neither of them, though, was able to survive on her own, without rescue of some sort or another). When I was reading it, I thought: "Fun! He's playing with that old campy helpless-but-bitchy pseudo-feminist stuff." But, well, in light of his statements about the book, and about his goals - it seems that, maybe, um, he wasn't. If the real intent is to step beyond pastiche into something that stands on its own, outside of its references to old comics (Kirby or otherwise), and can be taken seriously as a character study, or even as a meaningful action-adventure, then Casey and Scioli have a long way to go. (Above is excerpted from my review at graphicnovelreview.com)
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
RETRO LEE & KIRBY!, May 30, 2006
This review is from: Godland, Vol. 1: Hello, Cosmic! (v. 1) (Paperback)
No, Godland isn't a long lost Jack Kirby story that was recently found although no one would fault you for jumping to that conclusion. Rather it's Joe Casey and Tom Scioli's tribute/reset on Kirby and Stan Lee work of the 60's, combining elements of the Fantastic Four along with Kirby's cosmic work of The New Gods, and the Eternals/Celestials, and that's just for starters. The pair hit on various Lee & Kirby creations ranging from the late 1950's through the 1970's, albeit with a more complex storyline for 21st century audiences. As a meteor crashes near the Great Wall of China, the cosmic hero Adam Archer flies to investigate as we learn about his origin in a series of flashbacks. He was an astronaut on a mission to Mars and the lone survivor when their ship crashed. Near death, he stumbled upon an ancient alien machine and transformed into a being of awesome cosmic power by a group of alien minds. This harkens back to the days of the creation of beings such as the Silver Surfer and Adam Warlock. Investigating the meteor, Archer finds it contained a life form...a giant reptilian dog-like form that looks like one of those monsters created by Kirby in the pre-hero days of Marvel/Atlas comics that had names like Groom or Grok. A battle ensues but soon the arch villain Basil Cronus arrives on the scene and has his own designs on the alien mutt. Cronus is another great throwback to the 60's...a humanoid body with a skull floating in a vat of fluid for a head. While all of this is going on, America's most cherished hero "Crashman" has gone missing and been captured in the Arctic Circle by a villainess named Discordia. There's a part in Godland that really made me laugh...as Archer battles the alien dog he chides himself for trash-talking while fighting...which of course is something that Stan Lee loved to have his heroes do in his stories. Very clever. Tom Scioli does a great job imitating Kirby's art style. I will note, however, that the Kirby he's replicating is more the mid-70's Kirby as opposed to the 60's "classic" Kirby. Still for Kirby fans it works as a wonderful tribute to the old master and Scioli obviously put in a lot of time studying Jack's work. He's got a lot of the nuances down pat, such the multitude of spots in Archer's "cosmic powers" right down to the facial expressions of the characters. The only short-coming for me was the plot which was far more complex than anything Kirby and Lee would have created. I realize that audiences are more sophisticated today than they were 35 or 40 years ago, but I think it would have worked a bit better if the story were also kept in the Lee style. Still, it was a fun retro take on 60's material. Reviewed by Tim Janson
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|